Tag Archives: europe

Certification Uncertainty

By Anna Simet | May 06, 2013 Sustainably sourcing biomass fuel isn’t something that’s taken lightly in the U.K., and the country is proving it by developing the first nationwide mandatory biomass sustainability standards. As its Renewables Obligation continues to ramp up, the amount of biomass that power utilities will require may significantly increase, and the U.K. is determined to ensure that feedstocks are sourced responsibly. The RO, a policy mechanism similar to a state renewable portfolio standard in the U.S., requires licensed electricity suppliers in the U.K. to source an increasing amount of electricity from renewable sources. Biomass, particularly imported wood pellets, are an attractive replacement for facilities using coal, and imports from North America are increasing at a rapid rate. Currently, the country sets general restrictions for biomass materials sourced from land with high biodiversity value or high carbon stock, including primary forest, peatland and wetlands. But this approach has proven untenable over the past two years, according to Suz-Anne Kinney of Forest2Market, as there has been some disagreement over definitions, and because current forest certification schemes alone are not sufficient to meet the criteria. The U.K. Department of Energy and Climate Change proposed new sustainability criteria last September and a comment period wrapped up at the end of November, but the official standards are yet to be released. As proposed, a biomass power facility would have to demonstrate that 70 percent of the wood used to manufacture the pellets it procures has chain-of-custody (COC) certification, from the forest of origin to the final user. “In order to demonstrate compliance, a supplier must provide independent COC certification of the timber or timber products by one of the major certification schemes,” explains Kinney. “In the U.S., especially in the South where the majority of industrial pellet mills are or will be located, widespread certification of this type is not common. As mills purchase wood from dozens of different dealers, brokers or loggers who buy the timber from hundreds of landowners, the scope of any project to increase certification will require significant resources.” So the big question is: will part of the criteria include this requirement of third-party verification of raw material? While it may sound suitable on the exterior, such a requirement may pose significant challenges to U.S. biomass exporters, and some believe sets unachievable  expectations. Certification and Ownership “The problem is that there is a very low percentage of timberland that is actually certified, so it would be very difficult to procure 70 percent of material from certified forests,” explains Seth Walker, RISI bioenergy economist. “In the U.S., less than 25 percent is certified, and in the South, it’s 22 percent. Actively managed and harvested timber, less than a quarter of it is certified.” According to Robert Simpson, senior vice president of Sustainable Forests & Forest Product Certification at GreenWood Global Consulting, sourcing 70 percent of pellet feedstock from certified sources “will be impossible, unless you have a very large supplying force nearby,” he says. “If you’re depending on many ma and pop forest owners, it’ll be very difficult.” And that’s largely the case for biomass sourcing in the Southeast, where about 67 percent of commercial-value forests are privately owned. The forest industry owns another small portion, Simpson says, and the federal government an equal portion. “Interestingly, out of the 134 million acres of procurable  and useable forestland in the Southeast, only 3 percent have long-term management plans,” says Simpson.  Furthermore, only 13 percent have formal management advice. That’s very minimal compared to Europe, according to Simpson, where 77 percent have some type of professional forest management advice. That leads buyers in the European Union to wonder why forest owners in the U.S. aren’t certified, when the forests of Europe are regulated and strictly managed. In the U.K, about two-thirds of land is privately owned—very close to the portion that is privately-owned in the U.S.—but both countries differ from the norm, as it is estimated that of the 3.9 billion hectares of the world’s forests, 86 percent are publicly owned. If the U.K. policy comes through as proposed—requiring forest certification—or if an end user demands a high percentage of certified material anyway, it just won’t be found, says Simpson. “It’s not there, especially for the larger facilities.” He recommends smaller family forestland owners contemplating certification to look into group certification, which goes fairly quickly and is less expensive, as it allows multiple forest owners to become certified as a group and share financial costs. Essentially, the motivation behind the standards stems from the carbon accounting question. “If you cut down trees and don’t replant, the carbon story is very different [than if trees are replanted],” says Walker. “There are really two reasons why the U.K. likes certification and sees it as ideal, but at the same time, they know the forests in North America are managed pretty well, and there aren’t any major issues with deforestation or bad practices.” That’s evidenced by the increasing/stable forest area cover in most U.S. regions. “We have growth exceeding removals, so it’s a pretty good story, but it’s tough to put that [sustainable] stamp on it,” Walker says. One of the main reasons for that is there is a great history of family-owned forests, especially in the Northeast and the Southeast; in the Pacific Northwest there is more federal, state and consolidated land.  “So, the Smith family in Virginia has 50 acres of forest and a forester comes in every 10 years and maybe cuts 12 of the 50 acres, in 20 years a thinning, then in 40 years do a clear cut and then replant,” explains Walker. “Someone like that isn’t going to have any incentive to go through all of the red tape to get that land certified. The biggest indicator of whether land will be certified sustainable, in the U.S., is whether it is owned by a large land owner or financial landowner.” Looking Ahead If forest certification isn’t required, what might be the alternative? “Right now, each of the utilities have to audit their own supply chain, so there might just be some due-diligence requirements, as far as the forest stock around the areas they’re procuring fiber from for wood pellets,” suggests Walker. There could also be group certification [requirements] where an entire state would become certified to meet necessary standards. “That hasn’t happened on a big scale yet, but it has happened on smaller scales,” says Walker. For example, FSC worked with a large group of Wisconsin landowners for certification and brought 31,000 new participants into the certification program, more than 2 million acres of privately owned land. “The major conservancy and the SFI (Sustainability Forestry Initiative) are working together to find gaps in the certification program and see if they can fix them,” Walker adds, one of which is the small landowner problem. The National Wildlife Federation is one of those groups working to recruit smaller forest owners to get certified under FSC, and suggests one way to alleviate the cost to smaller landowners is by sharing the cost with the buyer. “We know that in the Southeast and other regions of the country, not all forest owners can afford to get certified, and so we believe that pellet manufacturers and other bioenergy facilities could help cover the cost of assuring regulators and the public at large that their bioenergy sources are truly sustainable,” says F.G. Beauregard, NWF Southeast Sustainable Bioenergy manager. So whether forest certification will ultimately be required is unclear, but in the meantime, what can pellet exporters be doing to prepare for what might potentially be enforced? The first thing is getting chain of custody under these certification schemes, according to Walker. COC verifies company systems for tracking and handling materials used in FSC-certified forest products within the company’s operations. Another major preparation measure is securing a supply contract with a large landowner, particularly a financial landowner. “Despite the majority of the actively managed timberland being owned by smaller landowners, there still are very large tracks owned by financial landowners, and those are mostly certified,” says Walker. “So, it is possible to get most or all of your timber from a certified source, if you’re located in the right place and can set up the right agreement.” So, are the standards likely to remain as proposed? “My hunch is no, because there has been so much invested…it would really almost halt the industry, a strict standard like that,” says Walker. “Again, part of the issue is the whole carbon balance, carbon is actually the main issue; they [utilities] have to show a net reduction of carbon over coal. They’re concerned about sustainability on one hand, not wanting to promote any sort of bad forestry practices, but they also want that stamp that says whichever forest the wood came from is managed and has a plan to be replanted.” Author: Anna Simet Managing Editor, Biomass Magazine 701-751-2756 asimet@bbiinternational.com Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Investment, investments, News, Property, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Certification Uncertainty

United States: Can California Cap And Trade If Brussels Stumbles?

08 May 2013 Article by Jeffrey Rector Last week, the European Parliament rejected a proposal to reduce the quantity of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions allowances in order to fix a supply-demand imbalance in the European Union Emissions Trading System (EU ETS). Some view this as the beginning of the end of the European Union’s ten-year carbon cap-and-trade experiment. A high profile failure of the EU ETS is likely to provide ammunition to critics California’s cap-and-trade program. An emissions offset or emissions allowance (representing the right to emit one metric ton of CO 2 or GHG equivalent, or CO 2 e) within EU ETS is no longer trading at values that promote investment in low carbon technologies, and therefore the EU ETS is not presently serving its core purpose. The trading value of an EU Emissions Allowance was above €30 per metric ton in 2008 before the sharp impacts of the global recession. Prices halved in late 2008 and early 2009 and hovered around €15 for two years until 2011. Then prices began a steady decline to €10, then €5, and now even less. It is understood by energy and climate economists that if emissions allowances can be purchased for less than €10, a cap-and-trade system will have little if any effect on the pollution abatement decisions of heavy emitters because the allowances would be cheaper than virtually all known or developable emissions abatement technologies. Indeed, such rock bottom prices may have the effect of promoting high-emitting technologies that should be discouraged. At issue is an oversupply of credits: (i) the EU was too generous in its granting of free allowances; (ii) international offsets from the tradable credit programs under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (including the Clean Development Mechanism) outstripped demand; and (iii) the global recession reduced the demand for energy and thereby the demand for credits, which drives pricing. The EU Parliament recently voted whether to defer the issuance of a portion of new emissions allowances (referred to as “backloading”) in order to constrain supply and raise prices. When the final votes were tallied, the backloading proposal was rejected by a narrow margin. It is said that carbon markets viewed the outcome as a vote of no-confidence in the future viability of the EU ETS, which had pushed the trading price of allowances to the current price of less than €3 per metric ton. The backloading proposal will likely be reconsidered by the EU Parliament early this summer, but its prospects are uncertain. While it is impossible to reduce the basis for opposing backloading to a single idea, it seems that, even in Europe, there is almost irresistible pressure to give economic growth precedence over reducing emissions; and it appears that Europe, much like the United States, is still struggling with the question of whether the two objectives (economic growth and emissions reduction) can be simultaneously advanced. For at least two reasons, the European experience does not bode well for California’s fledgling carbon market. First, it demonstrates the difficulty of creating a market in tradable rights to undertake a previously unregulated activity. The cost of emitting greenhouse gasses has heretofore gone unaccounted for and been externalized. A cap-and-trade system creates scarcity in the right to emit and allocates those rights for free or fee to regulated entities. While cap-and-trade may be a “market-based” solution, the allocation of emissions allowances is, in fact, a political decision that produces winners and losers. Thus, the true test for the political viability of a cap-and-trade system is when the emissions allowances are no longer given away; the EU ETS was beginning to enter this phase, and the strength of the opposition from the heavy emitters predictably increased. The California Legislature has delegated the difficult political decision of allocation to the California Air Resources Board, which partially insulates the allocation decision from political pressure; however, the scope of the delegation to CARB arguably undermines the legitimacy, and possibly the legality, of CARB’s cap-and-trade decisions. Second, the California Legislature viewed it to be in California’s best interest to be a leader in regulating carbon (and in policy circles, a leader in cap-and-trade) on the assumption that other states and the federal government would follow. A high profile failure of carbon cap-and-trade across the Atlantic would be a setback for the prospects of a national policy being implemented in the near future, and the cost of leading when there are no followers might not be one the majority of Californians will be willing to pay. Parties interested in the fate of California’s cap-and-trade system will likely be following this developing story in Europe and waiting for another EU vote, which is expected to come early this summer. The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances. Specific Questions relating to this article should be addressed directly to the author. Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Investment, investments, News, Property, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on United States: Can California Cap And Trade If Brussels Stumbles?

New Tax Havens In Search For Investors After Cyprus Scandal

New tax havens in search for investors after Cyprus scandal © Photo: www.tOrange.biz Download audio file Financial consultants that are good at keeping money hidden and safe got a new challenge recently. Right after the Cyprus scandal they had to offer something more reliable. Hungry for fresh money that without any question sooner or later will burst through Cypriot financial border, other tax havens started promoting themselves. Switzerland, Luxembourg and Caiman Islands, as well as a host of other locations, including Dubai and Singapore, are looking for investors. And recently they have found their first ones. The Russian banks changed their offshore accounts residency when issuing Eurobonds. According to open sources financial Moscow-based organizations like VTB and Sberbank increased they are investments in foreign bonds issued in Luxembourg, Netherlands and Ireland multiple times. It is just for safety? Russian economist, Sergey Alexashenko, gave an interview to the Voice of Russia. Greetings Sergey! Good evening! How are you? I’m pretty good, thanks. I hope you too. Let’s clear up for our listeners why should companies invest in foreign papers in the first place? Is it good when money work for a native of economy? It is interesting that there is little bit of misunderstanding. Cyprus was used by the Russian companies and banks as a jurisdiction for their special purpose vehicle companies that were issued to Europe for Eurobonds. For example, the Russian legislation does not allow to fit all the requests of international investors and that’s why for issuing Eurobonds, Sberbank or VTB, they have established previously a special company in Cyprus under Cyprus law and under the jurisdiction of the High Court of London and that’s why it was easier to have access to investors. And after Cyprus lost its credibility Russian corporates and bank, they are not sure about the future of such companies and they are looking for other jurisdictions for the same purposes – just to establish special companies that will issue Eurobonds for their mother companies that are domiciled in Russia. According to the latest reports EU is really tightening the nuts, even Luxemburg set the date to lift bank secrecy rules. The new policy will take effect in 2015. But that’s just for the EU citizens. What about international corporations? Don’t you think they will be next? Yes you are right. There is another side of the story that the European authorities, as well as American authorities, they try to press offshore countries to increase taxes. That is a financial mechanics and it will affect many companies. And that’s why the decision of Luxemburg to open the banking secrecy, to make it more transparent for tax authorities is as well the result of the pressure from the European authorities to make life for national budgets easier, it is not an easy time for them. German Finance Minister said that the problem that sparked Cyprus scandal was very simple – the country just doesn’t produce enough goods or services to keep the economy balanced. I agree with him. I think that the problem of Cyprus is that two Cyprus banks were oversized. They were much bigger than the size of the Cyprus economy. They have raised enormous amount of deposits and invested much cash in Greek economy. And because of the crisis in Greece banks met losses. It is not the question of stability of the Cyprus economy or anything else. What other tax havens may offer their services? And where is the end to tax havens? Will they be closed? I’m afraid it is not possible to close all tax havens and all offshore countries because it is required for financial mechanics. Caiman Islands legislation is well fitted for investors. Bahaman legislation is well fitted for trusts and so on. So, in the world we have more than 200 counties and I’m afraid it is not possible to make all of them equal in fighting offshore, in fighting tax haven. Moreover, in many-many financial instruments you need jurisdictions with lower taxation where you wouldn’t lose money if you transfer cash from one economy to another. Read more: http://english.ruvr….4_30/214184615/ Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Dubai, Greece, Investment, investments, London, News, Property, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on New Tax Havens In Search For Investors After Cyprus Scandal