News
Land Value Blast
FIGURES proclaiming a boom in Scottish farmland values have been slammed as the work of industry professionals ‘talking up’ a market that rewards them on a percentage commission basis. There are some who say land values should be based on what the land can produce Outspoken land reformist Andy Wightman this week took a swipe at the Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors after the positive results of its Rural Land Market Survey were widely reprinted in the national press and media. Mr Wightman branded reports that repeated the headline ‘farmland hits a record high’ as misleading, and challenged the factual basis of RICS’ claim that farmland prices had more than trebled in less than a decade. The land campaigner highlighted that these figures actually stemmed from the surveyed ‘opinion’ of members of RICS – not their actual sale statistics. Mr Wightman said on his blog: “Looking at the Rural Market Survey report itself (which is only available if you register as a RICS site user), things become clearer. “The claim that ‘prices had trebled in less than a decade’ is based upon an ‘opinions based’ measure, which is a hypothetical estimate by surveyors of the value of pure bare land. “As the small print makes clear: ‘Net balance data is opinion based; it does not quantify actual changes in an underlying variable’,” he noted.”It is also a UK wide figure and thus says nothing about the farmland market in Scotland.” RICS spokeswoman Sue Steer declared at the time of release of the figures that: “The growth in farmland prices in recent times has been nothing short of staggering. In less than 10 years we’ve seen the cost of an acre of farmland grow to such an extent that investors – not just farmers – are entering the market. “If the relatively tight supply and high demand continues, we could experience the cost per acre going through the £10,000 barrier in the next two to three years,” she ventured. In his withering put-down, Mr Wightman countered: “What she really means is that’s the cost of an acre of land according to the opinion of her members. And when she speculates that the cost per acre could go through the £10,000 barrier in the next two or three years – that too is simply the opinion of those with a vested interest in precisely that outcome,” said Mr Wightman. That ‘vested interest’ is something the Scottish Tenant Farmers Association is also concerned with, particularly as it fears these buoyant prices will heighten landlords’ expectations in the next round of rent reviews in November. Chairman Christopher Nicholson said: “The capital cost of land rarely reflects its agricultural productivity and this is as true in the rental market as scarcity causes rents to overtake profitability. It is high time that common sense was brought to bear and sitting tenant rents become based on the real worth of the land, that is, what the farm can produce rather than what it could fetch in an over-heated market stoked by profit driven land agents.” STFA would, he said, be using the forthcoming review of agricultural holdings to press for radical change to the way in which farm rents are set to ensure tenants’ businesses are not ‘crippled by unreasonable rent demands’. Responding to this furore, RICS Scotland director Sarah Spiers said: “Over the last decade, the bi-annual RICS Rural Land Market Survey, undertaken by our members in Scotland, has proven to be a leading indicator for the rural sector. “It provides local-level knowledge and insight from chartered surveyors working in the rural and land sectors in Scotland, rather than official views of company research departments. “It is not in the interest or benefit of RICS members in Scotland to ‘talk up the market’; it is their responsibility to report the market accurately, not steer it,” she insisted. Commenting on the RICS survey – and the STFA’s warning – landowners’ body Scottish Land and Estates insisted that recent increases in land values were not the reason for rises in agricultural rents. SLaE director, Andrew Howard, said: “The fundamental point is that farm rents are good value and this has been reflected by official statistics published by the Scottish Government this year. “The main driver for any increases in rent is productivity of the farm, not the capital value of the land. More often than not when agriculture is not doing so well then rents remain fairly static. There have been rises in recent years because farming has been having a good period of productivity. “The other important factor in rent reviews is that it is only in recent years that reviews have been conducted on farms where the rent had been unchanged for a very long time,” he added. “Land capital values generally do not influence rent calculations and if there are rent increases later this year this will not be the reason,” he maintained. Continue reading
Brakes Being Applied To Rapid Rise In Farmland Values?
August 28, 2013 8:30 am • By Jane Fyksen Crops Editor Is the party coming to an end? That is the question raised by the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago’s August farmland values and credit conditions report. Even though for second-quarter 2013, “good” farmland was up 17 percent from a year ago in the Seventh District, which includes three-fourths of Wisconsin, ag land values registered no gain in the second quarter relative to the first quarter this year, according to 211 ag bankers in the district. “The last time there was no quarterly increase in agricultural land values was in 2009,” says David Oppedahl, business economist with the Chicago Reserve. “Generally, the stellar year-over-year gains in farmland values across the five district states masked the comparative weakness of the quarterly results.” Further, Oppedahl reports that the percentage of ag bankers in this quarterly survey anticipating farmland values to fall during the present third quarter (July-September) is the same as those predicting land value to rise (both 7 percent). Eighty-six percent think farmland values will be stable in the third quarter. As noted, the Seventh District’s survey of ag bankers includes three-quarters of the state, generally all but the northwest section. From July 1, 2012, to July 1, 2013, they saw land values in Wisconsin up 7 percent, 6 percent in the more southeasterly counties, 11 percent in the more central portion of the state and 16 percent in the southwest, which is generally included with northeast Iowa in the survey; however, in the second quarter (April 1 to July 1, 2013), ag bankers say the value of “good” farmland in Wisconsin only rose 1 percent. That is based on a 6 percent rise across the state’s midsection, but a 3 percent drop in southeastern and eastern counties up along Lake Michigan. Southwestern counties, lumped in with northeast Iowa, saw a 2 percent second-quarter hike. Year-to-year changes and second-quarter 2013 changes, respectively, for other district states are as follows Illinois (the northern two-thirds), up 17 percent, down 1 percent; Indiana (up 21 percent, up 5 percent); Iowa, up 18 percent, unchanged in recent months; and Michigan, up 18 percent, down 7 percent. Oppedahl highlights the second-quarter pause in what is been a rapid rise in farmland values in recent years, and he points to the quarterly decreases in ag land values in Illinois and Michigan. While farmland values on a year-over-year basis “still appear to be soaring,” he notes that “changes in farmland values on a quarterly basis may be presaging shifts in the year-over-year pattern in the latter half of 2013.” The year-over-year increase in farmland values for the second quarter was larger than that for the previous one – 17 percent versus 15 percent reported in June. Ag bankers, like producers, are seeing key crop prices starting to slide, and wondering if land values With larger harvests anticipated this fall to bolster crop supplies, USDA estimates price intervals for the 2013-2014 crop-year of $4.50 to $5.30 a bushel for corn and $10.35 to $12.35 for soybeans. “Given these price ranges, the district’s 2013 corn and soybean harvests would be lower in value compared with its 2012 harvests,” notes Oppedahl. While some of the lost revenue will be recouped via crop insurance payments for prevented plantings and revenue protection policies, this Federal Reserve economist cautions that “the anticipation of lower crop revenues – especially combined with potentially rising interest rates on farm loans – portended softness in future farmland values.” As for credit conditions in the district, he reports they were generally better in the second quarter than a year earlier. Ag bankers had more funds for lending, and repayments rates for non-real-estate farm loans were higher than a year ago. Ninety-four percent of responding bankers said their ag loan portfolios were having no significant repayment problems during April, May and June, and they perceived non-real-estate loan demand for the period to be below what it was during the same three months last year. Interest rates on farm loans rose in the second quarter for the first time since early 2011. That followed record-low rates in the previous quarter. As of July 1, district averages for interest rates on new farm operating loans and real estate loans were 4.94 percent and 4.65 percent, respectively, both lower than a year ago. “The uptick in interest rates on farm loans may mark an important shift in the district’s agricultural credit conditions,” Oppedahl warns. “Demand for non-real-estate loans relative to a year ago fell during the second quarter of 2013, but not as sharply as it did during the first quarter,” says Oppedahl. “With 17 percent of survey respondents reporting higher demand for non-real-estate loans compared with a year ago, and 30 percent reporting lower, the index of loan demand was 97 for the second quarter of 2013 – higher than its reading of 67 for the first quarter. Moreover, in the first six months of 2013, the amount of farm operating loans generated by banks was lower-than-typical, whereas the amount of farm mortgages was higher than typical.” Given such low demand for non-real-estate farm loans, it’s “not surprising,” he notes, that the district’s average loan-to-deposit ratio remained quite low at 64.5 percent – “well below the ratio desired by responding bankers (77.2 percent).” Bankers anticipate operating loans and livestock loans to shrink in this third quarter, relative to July-September last year; however, falling crop prices should bring some relief to livestock producers, who have suffered in recent years with high feed prices, Oppedahl says. Continue reading
Indiana’s Farmland Values Up Again In 2013
Thursday, August 29, 2013 WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. — Last year’s drought did little to slow the pace of rising farmland values and cash rents. They are up this year in a big way again, according to a Purdue University study. Drought last year sent corn and soybean prices soaring to all-time highs, which, along with crop insurance indemnities, meant better-than-expected farm incomes. High net farm income, low interest rates and high farmland demand with limited supply combined to push the state’s land values upward by anywhere from 14.7 to 19.1 percent, depending on productivity. Statewide cash rents increased by 9.4 to 10.9 percent. “While the 2012 Indiana crop suffered from the worst drought since 1988, the increase in farmland values did not bother to slow down,” said Craig Dobbins, Purdue Extension agricultural economist. The biggest increases were in high-productivity land, which jumped by 19.1 percent to $9,177 per acre. Average-productivity land increased 17.1 percent to $7,446 per acre, and poor-productivity land was up by 14.7 percent to $5,750 per acre. Land values, cash rents and farmland productivity were estimated for the study by surveying Indiana rural appraisers, agricultural loan officers, Farm Service Agency personnel, farm managers and farmers. The 261 respondents were asked to estimate long-term corn yields for poor, average and top-quality land. The state’s average long-term corn yields for poor, average and top-quality land were 127, 160 and 193 bushels per acre, respectively. Another area that saw growth is the transitional land market, Dobbins said. “The transitional land market — that is, farmland moving out of agriculture — seems to have sprung back to life,” he said. “This is a specialized market, with transitional land value strongly influenced by the planned use and location.” Overall, the survey showed a 24.4 percent increase in average transitional land value, up to $10,581 per acre. However, the estimated values from the 2013 survey varied widely — from $2,500 to $45,000 per acre. The median value was $9,500 per acre — $1,500 per acre more than in 2012. “Because of the wide variation in transitional land values, the median value might give a more meaningful picture than the average,” Dobbins said. Cash rents increased statewide, with the largest jump found in high-productivity land. Top-quality land increased by 10.9 percent or $29 per acre. Rent for average-quality land was up by 10.1 percent, or $21 per acre, and rent for poor-quality land was up 9.4 percent, or $15 per acre. The survey also assessed expectations for where farmland values and cash rents are headed in the future. Dobbins said the consensus is that increases will slow and, in some regions, values might stall or decline slightly. Forty-three percent of the survey participants said they thought farmland values would increase by an average 11.7 percent over the next five years. That means they expect an average annual increase of 2.2 percent. Thirty-five percent of the respondents thought farmland values would decline by an average of 12.3 percent over the next five years — an annual decline of 2.3 percent. The remaining 22 percent expected no change. Continue reading




