TSI
Climate Change: Russia Is Steamed About U.N.’s Kyoto Carbon Credit COP-Out
Representatives of Russia and other Eastern bloc countries at the recent climate talks in Bonn made it clear that they aren’t one bit happy about efforts within the U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change’s Conference of Parties (COP) to cap their free Soviet-era carbon credit trading green stamps previously gifted to them under the Kyoto Protocol. The original deal was that signatory nations that reduced carbon emissions by targeted amounts under their 1990 levels would be able to sell credits based upon tonnage improvements to countries that produced more than their allocations, thereby meeting quotas. In other words, a market was created to sell lots of hot air…something that the U.N. excels at. The idea, at least as presented by the FCCC, was to save our planet from dreaded CO 2 -induced global warming. Incidentally, we might have credited that plan for great success were it not for the fact that while global temperatures have been flat now for about 17 years, those atmospheric CO 2 levels have continued to rise. Yeah, But Russia Expected That All Along Originally, Russian President Vladimir Putin announced on December 2, 2003, that his country would not ratify the Kyoto Protocol because the rationale supporting it was “scientifically flawed”. He argued that even one hundred percent compliance with the agreement wouldn’t reverse climate change. The Russian Academy of Sciences presented scientific arguments against signing in a statement issued on July 1, 2005, noting that the world’s temperatures do not follow CO 2 levels. Instead, they observed a much closer correlation between world temperatures and solar activity. The Academy also determined that sea levels were not rising faster with warming; rather, they had been increasing steadily about 6 inches per century since the Little Ice Age ended in about 1850. In addition, the Academy discounted one of the most significant danger claims about global warming – that tropical diseases would spread – noting that malaria is a disease that is encouraged by sunlit pools of water where mosquitoes can breed, not by climate warmth. They also pointed out the lack of correlation between global warming and extreme weather, which a British government scientific delegation had admitted it could find no evidence to support. What ultimately caused Putin and the Russian duma to change their position and ratify the Protocol? It is widely speculated that Europeans were instrumental in getting Russia admitted to the World Trade Organization (WTO), and thus categorized it as a developing country rather than a developed one in applying the Protocol regulations. This meant that Russia received an opportunity to sell to European countries billions of dollars’ worth of Soviet-era emission credits associated with former dirty industries that had been casualties of economic melt-down. This would also help Europe meet Kyoto’s first-phase requirements without actually cutting emissions or energy use. Europe’s 1990 CO 2 emissions of 4,245 million tons fell to 4,123 tons in 2002 due to reductions in burning coal in both Britain and East Germany. Yet Kyoto Protocol requirements stipulated further European Union cutbacks to 3,906 million before 2012. A December 2003 U.N. report predicted that the E.U. would miss that reduction target by even more than that amount, namely, by dropping an additional 311 million tons. Since Russia’s 1990 emissions were 2,405 million tons, and had fallen by 2001 to 1,614 million tons, they could sell up to 800 million tons of credits to the Europeans at an “auction” price. This would be cheaper for Europe than shutting down fossil-fired power plants or removing trucks from its vital transportation infrastructure by means of escalating already high diesel fuel taxes. But Not Such a Great Deal for the U.S. Perhaps unsurprisingly, it wasn’t in the cards for the U.N. to offer the U.S. any breaks comparable to those accorded to the Europeans and Russians . First, unlike Europe and former Soviet countries that were treated as separate emission-credit-trading entities, the U.S. was treated as a single nation (allowing no credit exchanging between states to meet quotas). Second, the U.S. emissions in 1990 were not inflated to high target allowance levels as was the case in Germany, Britain, and Russia, making compliance much more difficult to achieve. In response to these inequities and other issues, our Senate passed (95-0) a rare unanimous bipartisan Byrd-Hagel U.S. Senate Resolution (S Res 98) that made it clear that the United States would not be signatory to any agreement that “would result in serious harm to the economy of the United States”. Then-President Clinton, no stranger to political pragmatism, got the message and never submitted a necessary U.S. Kyoto Protocol approval request for congressional ratification. Heated Climate Negotiations Put On Ice Reuters reported on June 6 that U.N. talks aimed at progress towards a new 2015 climate pact agreement have now been stalled by objections from Russia, Belarus and Ukraine regarding procedural violations purposefully intended to eliminate their free carbon food stamp lunch. The UNFCCC now wants to renege on a deal they made with Russia to get them into Kyoto in the first place. Now that European carbon markets have recently collapsed with the price of carbon (hot air) hitting record lows, they are concerned that allowing Russia, Ukraine, Poland and other former Soviet bloc nations to retain the huge stockpile of carbon credits they picked up under Kyoto would further flood and depress the market. Ironically, those credits were originally granted as a reward to former Eastern bloc nations for the Communism which depressed their economic development prior to 1990, essentially compensating them for the economic destruction wreaked by their own Communist regimes. Poland, which will host COP 19 in November, has approximately 500 metric tons of carbon credits it plans to continue to sell to other nations including Japan, Ireland and Spain to offset its emissions from heavy coal use. Russia has since announced that it will not be part of a second Kyoto commitment period under these conditions, saying that they are committed to keep the credits and sell them to other countries regardless of a claimed COP “consensus” that would terminate them. They are still smarting over a snub during two-week-long U.N. Climate talks in Doha, Qatari last year when, during the final minutes, Vice Prime Minister Abdullah bin Hamad al-Attiya ended the eighteenth Conference of the Parties (COP-18) before their delegation which wished to be recognized could speak. While Christiana Figueres, the U.N.’s climate chief, claimed that a consensus had been reached, Oleg Shamanov, the chief negotiator for Russia’s delegation called that an “absolutely obvious violation of this procedure.” Shamanov added, “This is a systemic issue. Unless we put our house back in order, we may not be able to guarantee that in 2015 we end up with something productive.” Capitalizing on Wealth Transfer from Capitalism Carbon credit cap-and-trade marketing is but one U.N. climate alarm-based profiteering scheme aimed at global wealth redistribution. Another important agenda item for the UNFCCC’s 2015 Paris treaty to address is a planned “loss and damage” mechanism to seek compensation from “Tier 1” developed nations by a lawyered-up group of small island governments, the Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS), premised upon global warming hazards caused by industrialization. AOSIS leaders, including Tuvalu, Kirabati, St. Lucia, and the Maldives, claim that man-made global warming is causing super-hurricanes and rising sea levels. And who is most to blame? Coincidentally, of course, those legions of lawyers have identified culprits with the deepest pockets…the U.S., Western Europe and Japan. Although China is now the world’s largest CO 2 emitter, they got a pass. Still to be determined, is the problem of how such penalties should be assessed. For example, if a Category 4 hurricane hits an island, how can anyone know which portion of that hurricane was caused by each nation? Also, how much of it was caused by those coal plants and SUVs, versus at Mother Nature’s sole discretion? The idea of penalizing the West for trumped-up past and future climate crimes is certainly not new. Prior to COP-15 (2009-Copenhagen), several Latin American nations, the Philippines and the African Union claimed that Western countries owed developing countries trillions of dollars. U.S. and European delegation representatives attending the Copenhagen Climate Conference initially agreed to provide their “fair share”, pledging $10 billion in compensation per year from 2010 to 2012, The offer was rejected as an insult, discussions were temporarily interrupted as representatives of several undeveloped countries walked out of the meetings, and angry riots broke out in the streets over the injustice of such paltry penance. Then-Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez told the audience where to lay the blame for the world’s social, economic and climate problems: “If the climate was a bank, [the West] would already have saved it”. “The destructive model of capitalism is eradicating life”. “Our revolution seeks to help all people…Socialism, is the other ghost that is probably wandering around this room, that’s the way to save the planet; capitalism is the road to hell…Let’s fight against capitalism and make it obey us”. Then-Secretary of State Hillary Clinton then came to the rescue, offering to up the ante with a $100 billion annual contribution from the United States and our more prosperous friends to the “poorest and most vulnerable [nations] among us” by 2020. She said that the money would come from “a variety of sources, public and private, bilateral and multilateral, including alternative sources of finance”. Where it would actually come from no one knew, including Hillary and her boss. (Any guesses?) Time to End the Climate of Insanity It’s way past time to recognize that UNFCCC’s cap-and-trade, loss and damage compensation and other global wealth redistribution agendas have little or nothing to do with actually preventing a climate crisis, much less offering any benefits. Despite rising atmospheric CO 2 levels, global temperatures have not only been flat for going on two decades, but are predicted by leading scientists to cool over many future years or decades to come. Russia entered into the Kyoto Protocol realizing prior to that time that there was no convincing scientific climate-related basis for doing so. More recent determinations by researchers at their prestigious Pulkovo Observatory in St. Petersburg project that the global average yearly temperature will soon begin to decline into a very cold and protracted climate phase. Pulkovo Observatory head Dr. Habibullo Abdussamatov, one of the world’s leading solar scientists, member of the Russian Academy of Science, and director of the Russian segment of the International Space Station, believes that the deep freeze will last until the end of this century. He predicts that: “after the maximum of solar Cycle-24, from approximately 2014, we can expect the start of the next bicentennial cycle of deep cooling with a Little Ice Age in 2055 plus or minus 11 years” (the 19th to occur in the past 7,500 years). Dr. Abdussamatov points out that over the last 1,000 years deep cold periods have occurred five times. Each is correlated with declines in solar irradiance much like we are experiencing now with no human influence. “A global freeze will come about regardless of whether or not industrialized countries put a cap on their greenhouse gas emissions. The common view of Man’s industrial activity is a deciding factor in global warming has emerged from a misinterpretation of cause and effect.” Russian scientists Vladimir Bashkin and Raulf Galiullin from the Institute of Fundamental Problems of Biology of the Russian Academy of Science agree that climatic changes are characterized by natural cycles which have nothing to do with activities of man. As Bashkin observes: “A global warming that so many are talking about is not so much a scientific problem, rather it is much more a marketing trick…We do not have global warming ahead of us. Rather, we have global cooling.” Yes, and that marketing trick is one that the UNFCCC, including the Russian’s, has learned to play very well. Continue reading
‘Climate Bomb’ Warning Over China Coolant Release
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/1c273ab0-dbe4-11e2-8853-00144feab7de.html#ixzz2X7AUUxXp By Kathrin Hille in Beijing A “climate bomb” of potent greenhouse gases 15,000 times more damaging to the climate than carbon dioxide is set to be released by some of the world’s leading producers of refrigerants following a ban on climate credits. The companies, the majority of them in China, argue that a ban on trading of climate credits for the incineration of HFC-23 makes it no longer financially viable to destroy the gas, which is a byproduct of a substance used in air conditioners and refrigerators. A warning by the Environmental Investigation Agency in a report to be released on Monday will raise the pressure on China to ban such gases and end economic incentives for their production in multilateral talks. Some 19 factories – 11 in China – making HCFC-22 have been receiving climate credits under the UN’s Clean Development Mechanism for installing and operating incinerators to burn HFC-23 that is created during the manufacturing process, instead of venting it into the atmosphere. Facilities in developing countries can sell emission reduction credits to buyers in developed countries to allow the latter to meet their targets under the Kyoto protocol. However, the European Emissions Trading Scheme, the world’s largest carbon market, banned trading in those credits last month after finding that the financial incentive drove companies to produce more HFC-23 instead of curbing it. Other climate exchanges have said they will follow, causing substantial revenue streams for the producers to dry up. The EIA said an investigation had shown that most of China’s non-CDM facilities were emitting HFC-23 already. “If all of these facilities [under the CDM] join China’s non-CDM and vent their HFC-23, they will set off a climate bomb emitting more than 2bn tonnes of CO2 equivalent emissions by 2020,” it said. People involved in the sector in China said this was likely to happen. “If there is no more funding, the CDM plants could start venting as well,” Mei Shengfang, deputy secretary-general of the China Association of Fluorine and Silicone Industry, said. He added that authorities were considering offering support. An executive at China Fluoro Technology, one of the largest Chinese CDM plants, said: “Our company is still incinerating the HFC-23 now. If the money is used up, we can stop incineration. We can’t go on doing this, we can’t afford it and we have no duty to do it.” Releasing HFC-23 into the atmosphere is not illegal. China has been blocking proposals for a ban as part of multilateral talks under the Montreal Protocol to phase out hydrofluorocarbons, which continue on Monday in Bangkok. China raised hopes this month when President Xi Jinping and President Barack Obama of the US said at a summit that they had agreed to work together to reduce the production and consumption of hydrofluorocarbons. “This is a reversal of China’s attitude, and all eyes are on China now to see if it’s for real,” said Alexander von Bismarck, executive director at EIA. Additional reporting by Li Wan Continue reading
The bond of UK-UAE friendship
The bond of UK-UAE friendship Amanda Fisher / 24 June 2013 Amanda Fisher speaks with British Ambassador Dominic Jermey about the challenges of office, Shaikh Khalifa’s State visit to Britain and camel racing. What is your background? I used to be an investment banker and I graduated from Cambridge with a literature and philosophy degree. Between high school and university, I taught in a school in Chile and I asked the Rothschild family for sponsorship money to get there. After university, I wrote to them and said thanks for the sponsorship money, how about a job? After working in investment banking in several countries, I returned to the UK, where I learnt Urdu through the Foreign Office, which is how I got into the diplomatic service. I think now the Foreign Office is very keen to reach out to the private sector … somebody like me who’s been an ambassador they’d be very open to me going to work for five years for a major multinational and then returning. Diplomacy in Britain is a career, but it’s no longer a hermetically sealed one. In which other countries and in what capacity have you previously worked? After learning Urdu, I went to work in Pakistan for the Foreign Office, which I thoroughly enjoyed, before I moved on to Afghanistan where we were working with the Northern Alliance and the Taleban. We were very much focusing on supporting the UN-led peace initiatives in the 90s and supporting the United Nations anti-drug campaign. We had a very strong interest as at that time about 90 per cent of the heroin on British streets was from Afghanistan. In 1999, I relocated to the Balkans during the Kosovo crisis, then I moved to East Timor the next year while there was intervention on the genocide happening there. I returned to the United Kingdom working in peace-keeping, before I took up a post as the deputy ambassador in Spain in 2004, returning to the United Kingdom in 2007 to take a position as the managing director of UK Trade and Investment. How long have you been in the UAE? I have been in Abu Dhabi since 2010. Are you here with your family? If so, tell us about them. I don’t actually talk much about my family as I don’t think it is for public consumption, but it’s safe to say they have fun here, they really enjoy camel festivals, water sports, and being welcomed by Emiratis into their homes. I have a wife, who is a doctor, and two children who I think are much more likely to follow their mother into becoming a doctor rather than diplomacy. Living in different countries around the world is a fantastic way to grow up. What do you think are the successes of the UAE in its relationship with the UK? A matter of weeks after I got here, Prime Minister David Cameron came on his first trip in office. He set out a vision to sort of re-energise the relationship between the UK and the UAE and I’m very much the custodian of that relationship. It spreads across our people, 120,000 British nationals live in this country and choose to be here because they enjoy it and want to contribute to the development of this country. The royal families have close relations, and I saw that last month when the Queen invited the President, His Highness Shaikh Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nahyan and his brothers into her home. It was one of the first state trips that Shaikh Khalifa had done in a number of years and I think it’s a record actually that the Queen has done a visit to a country and in less than three years there’s been a return back, which speaks about the closeness of the relationship. There’s a very close political relationship, and we see that right now with the two countries cooperating on issues like Syria, which is one of the biggest challenges facing the world. We’ve also had a close military relationship for example in places like Afghanistan, where our servicemen serve alongside each other in harm’s way. And there’s a very close business relationship as well. At a recent Manchester City football match, I looked at the work done in the area by the UAE-UK Business Council, who have turned the area around the stadium into a business park, following on from Shaikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Presidential Affair’s, investments in Manchester City. While there are 5,000 British businesses operating in the UAE, I see business very much as a two-way street, with some outstanding UAE businesses operating in the UK. There is the London Gateway Business Port being built by DP World, which is a multi-billion dollar investment, we see The Abu Dhabi National Energy Company (TAQA) investing in the North Sea, and we see Masdar developing the London Array, which will be Northern Europe’s largest offshore wind farm. There’s a growing presence of Emirati businesses and investment in the UK. What do you think are the challenges faced by the UAE? I think this is a difficult neighbourhood, we’ve seen the economic benefit to the UAE from the Arab Spring in terms of migration of investment, but nevertheless, the old uncertainties of the stability of the Middle East have surfaced. As I look at what’s going on in Syria right now and the wider impact in terms of humanitarian issues and strong Islamist groups from around the region taking part in the fighting, I think that’s a grave concern for us and that’s a concern the Emiratis share. I look across the water to Iran and the nuclear programme, and I look at the UAE which is creating a gold standard civil nuclear programme completely aligned with the IAEA (International Atomic Energy Agency) and we compare that to the approach that Iran is taking from where they are making uranium enriched to a level that has no civil use, that of course is of grave concern. These are important issues that the UK will continue to discuss with the UAE government. What are your priorities in your role? My role is to make sure that all the many different parts of the bilateral relationship join up well and have real impact as more than the sum of the parts. It’s about making sure the relationships work in terms of foreign policy and business. I ensure when Shaikh Khalifa or His Highness Shaikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, Vice-President and Prime Minister of the UAE and Ruler of Dubai, visit Britain they meet the people they need to meet and vice-versa. There were 33 members of the royal family or Ministers from the UK who came to the UAE last year — part of my job is making sure those people meet the right people when they are here and that those meetings drive forward business in a way that is good for the UK and the UAE. It’s about something that works for the long term. What is the stance on visa requirements for Emiratis? There has been a lot of talk the UK will remove restrictions, allowing them to enter the country without a pre-approved visa. This is a really important issue for the Emiratis and I think the UAE Minister of Foreign Affairs, Shaikh Abdullah bin Zayed Al Nahyan, is playing a blinder in terms of getting progress, and we’re working on it. I think they’re putting forward a really excellent case, not just in the UK, but in many countries. I can’t say when there will be any progress, but we’re working on it. Do you think the two countries will continue their historical closeness? I think it’s a relationship that will last long into the future, it’s got very strong roots, and importantly there are lots of people — Emiratis and Brits — who are working hard to develop what we do together, whether it’s military cooperation, trade cooperation or ties between the royal families. I think from these roots a really strong and healthy relationship will continue to grow. What is your favourite pastime in the UAE? I enjoy going to camel races, it’s great fun and it’s absolutely wild, actually. We kind of hurtle along in our 4 X 4, shouting at our camel while standing in the sun roof. I’ve also been skydiving with the British Army’s elite parachute regiment, The Red Devils, over Palm Jumeirah. That was a once in a lifetime experience, and I haven’t felt the need to go skydiving since. Where is your favourite destination in the UAE? I love Dubai, but I love Al Ain probably most of all. That’s where I go to relax. We have a house by the Oasis and I just love wandering through and reflecting on the way things used to be in the UK. amanda@khaleejtimes.com —Interview in abridged format Continue reading




