TSI
Shanghai To Fine Firms For Breaching CO2 Market Rules
15 Jul 2013 10:13 Last updated: 15 Jul 2013 13:37 BEIJING, July 15 (Reuters Point Carbon) – Shanghai companies that fail to surrender enough government-issued carbon permits for each tonne of CO2 they emit under the city’s Emissions Trading Scheme face government fines of up to 100,000 RMB ($16,000) and will be forced to buy permits in the market, according to draft rules released by city lawmakers. Shanghai plans to launch an emissions market before the end of the year, capping carbon dioxide emissions from 200 companies across a broad sector of the city’s economy, including big energy users such as Bao Steel, energy companies such as PetroChina as well as China Eastern Airlines. The city is one of seven designated regions in which the central government is trialing emission markets before rolling out a federal scheme later in the decade in a bid to rein in pollution and greenhouse gas emissions and improve energy efficiency. The release of draft rules on Friday reveal for the first time how lawmakers intend to enforce environmental laws on companies responsible for pumping out about 110 million tonnes of carbon dioxide each year. “It is urgent to make clear rules on the basic issues as for carbon trading…. (the rules) will provide strong legal support and protection to carry out the pilot ETS,” the draft rules said. As well as fines for companies failing to surrender permits, companies that obstruct independent auditors in reporting emissions face penalties of up to RMB50,000 per breach. Emitters will be able to reduce the cost of complying with the scheme by offsetting up to 5 percent of their emissions by buying carbon credits, known as Chinese Certified Emission Reductions, from domestic projects that cut emissions. The rules, which were published on the local government’s website on Friday, still need to be ratified by government officials before becoming law. China, the world’s biggest emitter has been plagued by environmental problems associated with its rapid increase in coal consumption, with smog engulfing many of its cities located across the eastern seaboard. To improve energy efficiency the nation has a target to cut the emissions intensity of its economy – emissions per unit of GDP – by up to 45 percent by the end of the decade. To help it meet that goal, Shanghai plans to cut its carbon intensity by 19 percent below 2010 levels by 2015 and wants to curb 2013 energy consumption below 118.4 million tonnes of standard coal equivalent, increasing by 4.18 percent year-on-year. The city of Shenzhen was the first region in China to launch a carbon market in July, with permits changing hands at about $4.50-5.00 each, roughly the same price as those in Europe. By Kathy Chen – kathy.chen@thomsonreuters.com and Andrew Allan Continue reading
‘A So-Called Market In Invisible Stuff’: The Meaning Of Tony Abbott’s Carbon Rhetoric
July 15, 2013 Ben Cubby Environment Editor Abbott slammed on ‘invisible substance’ Tony Abbott has attracted criticism for saying the ETS is a “so-called market” for an “invisible substance”. Autoplay ON Video feedback on Monday, answering his own rhetorical question about what a carbon trading scheme is. Abbott’s emission was received with glee on social media, where people pointed out that there are many “invisible substances” – natural gas, oxygen and bacteria spring to mind – that both have market value and are essential to life on Earth. It’s the latest in a long campaign to redefine the stuff that comes from burning coal as a “colourless, odourless gas”, a harmless three-way cuddle between one carbon and two oxygen atoms that, happily, provides “plant food”. But, while the “invisible substance” line is facile, it is worth examining a little more closely, because it contains a few hints about the opposition’s strategy. Opposition Leader Tony Abbott has ramped up his rhetoric against market regulation of carbon emissions. Photo: Jonathan Ng The phrase “so-called market” not only plays to the sympathies of people suspicious of money markets, it positions the Coalition as the party with the knowledge to discern real markets from fake ones. The “non-delivery” hints at Labor government unreliability, and the “no one” points to the ethereal nature of the carbon exchange mechanism, where permits have a set value for a set period of time, but become worthless after that, like unused movie tickets. The fact that you can’t really make a non-delivery to no-one seems to have escaped Abbott, but the staffer who penned the line could argue the twisted grammar echoes the confusing nature of an ETS that won’t actually reduce emissions for a few years. Best of all, “invisible substance” plugs into a medieval mistrust of scientists and their incomprehensible powers. The sentence links these modern-day alchemists together with the shadowy financiers who would run the so-called markets, trading invisibility while we pay for it. Or something. It suggests that Abbott is prepared to wear some public ridicule in exchange for speaking directly to that part of his supporter base that is unmoved by scientific evidence about global warming. Never mind that the Coalition is proposing to spend about $10 billion of the public’s money fighting an “invisible substance”. That can be hidden behind its earthy rhetoric of “direct action” and a “green army” getting its hands dirty with a hard day’s practical work. What the Coalition is really trying to do is wrest back control of the language of climate change, because if it can control the language, and debate on its own terms, it can win. Read more: http://www.theage.co…l#ixzz2Z8DAdFr5 Continue reading
Abbott On Carbon Trading: ‘Non-Delivery Of An Invisible Substance To No One’
Minister calls opposition leader ‘an economic illiterate and a climate change denier’ after he attacks emissions schemes Katharine Murphy , deputy political editor guardian.co.uk , Monday 15 July 2013 The federal opposition leader, Tony Abbott, in Sydney on Monday, said the world was turning its back on carbon pricing. Photograph: AAP/Paul Miller Tony Abbott has branded emissions trading a “so-called market” that deals in an “invisible substance”, carbon dioxide, as the Coalition digs in politically ahead of Labor’s looming overhaul of its clean energy package . Emissions trading is an internationally recognised market-based mechanism for reducing carbon pollution, and was the policy of the previous Howard government before it lost the election in 2007, but the opposition leader declared on Monday that carbon markets were not true markets because they traded an “invisible substance”. “This is not a true market,” Abbott told reporters during a campaign visit in Sydney. “Just ask yourself what an emissions trading scheme is all about. It’s a market, a so-called market, in the non-delivery of an invisible substance to no one.” A reporter inquired whether this made carbon markets just the same as financial markets. Abbott repeated his definition: “Let’s think about it. It’s a market in the non-delivery of an invisible substance to no one.” The opposition leader contended that the world was turning its back on carbon trading schemes and carbon taxes as policy mechanisms for reducing pollution. “Ever since Copenhagen it has been absolutely obvious that the world is not moving towards taxes, whether they are fixed taxes or floating taxes,” he said. “The world is moving towards the kind of direct action measures to improve the environment which the Coalition has long championed.” But during a recent appearance on the ABC’s Q&A program , the former Liberal leader Malcolm Turnbull appeared to suggest that direct action was a temporary policy for the Coalition on the way to joining other countries that have adopted market-based policies. The climate change minister, Mark Butler, blasted Abbott’s comments on Monday morning. “He has let the cat out of the bag again today. No matter how hard he tries to hide it, Tony Abbott is an economic illiterate and a climate change denier.” Abbott’s comments come as the government will unveil details this week of its plan to scrap the fixed price period of the carbon package. Labor says it intends to move to an emissions trading scheme from 1 July 2014 – one year earlier than currently legislated. The treasurer, Chris Bowen, is refusing to specify ahead of the formal announcement the cost to the budget of removing the fixed-price period. But he has indicated the cost to revenue is in the order of several billions. The finance minister, Penny Wong, said emissions trading was the lowest cost means of reducing pollution, and she blasted the Coalition’s direct action policy alternative. “That’s the whole point of an emissions trading scheme. You set a cap at the limit that you want to achieve and then you let firms work out how they achieve that. They can find the lowest cost way to reduce their emissions,” Wong told the ABC. “It’s a market-based mechanism – lower cost for families, lower cost for households. It stands in stark contrast to the kind of Soviet-style scheme that seems to be on offer from [opposition climate spokesman] Greg Hunt and Tony Abbott.” And with new opinion polls showing a federal election held today could deliver Australian voters another knife-edge result, Abbott used a breakfast television appearance to rule out negotiating with any crossbenchers to form a minority government along the lines seen in the 43rd parliament. “I don’t do deals. I do rule it out,” Abbott told the Nine Network. “I think that the Australian people are sick of hung parliaments.” Continue reading




