TSI

DECC Scientist Takes Green Groups’ To Task Over Biomass Claims

Greenpeace, Friends of the Earth and RSPB under fire from government for using unfinished research to campaign against carbon impact of biomass power By Jessica Shankleman 01 Aug 2013 Tension between the government and green groups over the environmental impact of biomass has cranked up a notch, after it emerged DECC’s chief scientist has written to three of the UK’s leading NGOs to criticise their publication of unfinished research as part of their campaign against biomass subsidies. Earlier this year, Greenpeace, RSBP, and Friends of the Earth (FoE) unveiled a factsheet claiming biomass generation in some instances produces more emissions than burning coal. Under the government’s current plans biomass energy will have to show lifecycle reduction in emissions of at least 60 per cent compared to emissions of the EU fossil fuel grid average, such as cutting down trees and transporting fuel. The government is expected to confirm the new sustainability standards for biomass this month, with the rules likely to come into effect next year. But green groups fear the new standard will not fully take account of the full lifecycle emissions associated with growing, harvesting and distributing biomass for fuel and have been lobbying for stricter sustainability standards on generators . They believe rising subsidies could cause a huge surge in demand for the UK’s forestry harvest over the next four years, potentially having an adverse impact on biodiversity and leading to greater reliance on imported biomass. The RSPB, Greenpeace and FoE factsheet Burning Wood for Power Generation , revealed preliminary findings of a nine-month research project by David Mackay, DECC’s chief scientific adviser, that was presented to them at a stakeholder meeting in March. Unlike Ofgem’s current carbon calculator, MacKay’s calculator includes the net reduction in the carbon stock caused by the removal of timber from forests, and the indirect emissions of burning biomass that would have been avoided if it had been used for other industries, such as construction. Mackay’s initial findings showed the carbon impact of biomass rises significantly when these two sources of emissions are taken into account. The preliminary results suggested biomass generation produces more emissions than burning coal in five scenarios of the 12 scenarios considered. The factsheet prompted an angry response from the biomass industry with the Renewable Energy Association’s Gaynor Hartnell accusing the NGOs of using “half baked” arguments to scaremonger the public about the impact of the sector. However, BusinessGreen has learnt the publication also drew criticism from MacKay, who accused the three NGOs of exploiting the “open and collaborative” approach to research at the department. A letter , released under freedom of information request, was sent to Rose Dickinson, parliamentary officer for RSPB, Mike Childs, head of policy, research and science for Friends of the Earth and Doug Parr, chief scientist of Greenpeace, on May 15th criticising the decision to publish data from the draft report. In the letter MacKay said he was both “surprised and disappointed” that the factsheet quoted his draft findings. Mackay said the NGOs had been told the calculator his team developed, known as the the Bioenergy Emissions and Counterfactual (BEaC) calculator, was not intended for public circulation until its final launch – originally expected this summer but since delayed to the Autumn. “I acknowledge that the factsheet describes BEaC as a prototype and the results as preliminary; but I don’t think using the material in this context without specific permissions accords with the spirit in which we shared the model with the reviewers,” he wrote. “I wish to continue an open and constructive relationship with all of DECC’s stakeholders and I would like to urge you to treat unfinished analysis and material shared for review with more care in future,” he concluded. All three NGOs have since told BusinessGreen they published the data in good faith, believing they had permission from DECC to share the information so long as it was made clear it was not the final version. They also all said they removed the BEaC information from their websites after receiving MacKay’s letter. Harry Huyton, head of climate change for the RSPB, defended its decision to publish, arguing DECC should be more transparent around its thinking on biomass. “The bigger point is that the [BEaC draft] findings were consistent with major research by the European Commission’s Joint Research Centre so we didn’t see it as controversial,” he said. “But we did see it as important and in the public interest for people to understand what this tool was showing.” Huyton also raised concerns that the government has delayed the final publication of the BEaC to Autumn, despite previously promising to published in the summer. He urged the government to include the findings of the BEaC in its final sustainability standard when it comes out this month. “We need an open public debate about impact of biomass and that’s in the interest of the industry as much as ours,” he said. “Otherwise, the risk is we repeat what we’ve seen in biofuels sector where denial of indirect impacts has mean that even now many years down the line we’re still having a big debate about how to get emissions right. We should get it right from the outset.” Childs similarly argued the preliminary findings were important for the future of the industry. “The draft results were very interesting – they showed that burning whole trees compared to trimmings was bad news for the climate,” he said. ” The companies involved in the industry may need to change their practices to make them sustainable.” Greenpeace’s Parr added that many other countries would be looking at the UK’s standards as a template and it was therefore crucial the government got it right first time. “We urgently need the best available science informing standards at UK and EU level given the reliance on bioenergy to reach renewable targets,” he added. However, a spokesman for the government maintained it was committed to supporting only sustainably produced bioenergy, which delivers “real” greenhouse gas savings, is cost effective, takes account of wider impacts across the economy, and manages possible risks such as adverse effects on food security and biodiversity. “We are developing a model BEaC to investigate the carbon impacts of different bioenergy feedstocks and help ensure we have robust evidence behind our bioenergy policies,” he said. “A preliminary version of the tool has been discussed with stakeholders, however, the tool is under development and is subject to review.” He added that the draft version of the model should not yet be used to draw firm conclusions. Paul Thompson, head of policy for the REA, said the letter highlighted the need for all sides of the debate to treat complex information on the environmental impact of biomass sensitively. “This letter confirms that certain groups have misused data from the Calculator, which was in draft form and not intended for public use, to support pre-existing positions,” he said. “It is important to be more careful in the treatment of these sensitive issues and data in order to advance the rational debate that we need on biomass sustainability. “We look forward to working with NGOs and the Government on implementing the forthcoming RO Sustainability Criteria in order to ensure high carbon savings and ecologically sustainable forestry practices.” Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Investment, investments, News, Property, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on DECC Scientist Takes Green Groups’ To Task Over Biomass Claims

São Paulo Eyes Biomass Boom

[background=rgb(0, 128, 1) !important]29/07/2013[/background] The Brazilian state of São Paulo is predicting a major increase in biomass-powered electricity this decade and beyond. The state government’s latest energy strategy identifies sugar cane fired generation plant as a major growth area to help hit a new 69% renewable energy target by 2020. Combustion of cane residues is set to rocket from 2565MW in 2010 to 8.6GW by the end of the decade. This will leap further to 17.2GW by 2035. Other biomass fuels are also set to rise in the 2010 to 2035 time period. Forestry by-products will grow from 591MW to 1431MW, energy from waste will increase from zero to 391MW, and biogas will aim to expand from 62MW to 157MW. Wind energy will play its part with 457MW to be installed over the next 22 years from a standing start in 2010. Governor Geraldo Alckmin (pictured) said the expansion will cement São Paulo’s position as the Brazilian state with the highest percentage of renewable energy. Image: São Paulo government / Edson Lopes Jr Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Investment, investments, News, Property, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on São Paulo Eyes Biomass Boom

GIB Invests £20 Million In Biomass

30 July 2013 by Emma Leedham See an enlarged version of this infographic The construction of a wood-fuelled combined heat and power (CHP) station in Londonderry, Northern Ireland, was given the go ahead yesterday (29 July), after the Foresight Group and the UK Green Investment Bank plc (GIB) invested £20 million into the £81 million project. The investment has enabled the Evermore Renewable Energy CHP to be built on a ten-acre site at the Londonderry Port and Harbour Commissioners land at Lisahally. The project is forecast to be the largest renewable energy project in Northern Ireland, and is expected to operate from 2015 to 2035. According to the GIB, the 15.8 megawatt project – its first investment in Northern Ireland – will increase renewable electricity generation in the country by around 10 per cent, and deliver a reduction in greenhouse gas emissions of around 3.7 million tonnes. Partner funders include GCP Infrastructure Fund Ltd, Burmeister & Wain Scandinavian Contractor A/S (BWSC), Investec Bank, and Eksport Kredit Fonden.   Project details The CHP project, led by Evermore Renewable Energy (a subsidiary of the Evermore Group, founded in 2009) aims to supply enough renewable electricity to power more than 25,000 homes each year, create 200 construction jobs and over 20 full time jobs once in operation. Speaking of the project, Ciaran and Stephen Devine, co-founders of the Evermore Group commented: “We are making a serious commitment to the Northern Ireland energy market. Working with the best partners in technology, fuel supply and financing, we hope to show that Northern Ireland is a great place to do business so that further inward investment will follow. “This is the culmination of many years of hard work to develop and finance the largest green energy power station in Northern Ireland. Our ability to attract this level of investment into Northern Ireland is testament to our team’s commitment and skill in both project development and project financing. This now marks the start of the construction phase and with that the creation of over 200 much needed construction jobs in the North West.” They added that work should begin on the project in the ‘next six to eight weeks’. ‘Landmark moment’ for GIB Speaking of the investment, Shaun Kingsbury, Chief Executive of the UK Green Investment Bank, said: “[This] announcement will substantially increase Northern Ireland’s renewable energy capacity. Not only will the project save the same amount of carbon as taking around 77,000 cars off the road, it will also make use of over two million tonnes of wood, a valuable energy resource that would otherwise have gone to landfill.” The recycled wood (largely recovered from the construction and demolition industry) will be supplied under a fuel contract with Stobart Biomass Products Limited. Provision is being made to use up to 30 per cent of local wood biomass. Business Secretary Vince Cable said: “The first deal done in Northern Ireland is a landmark moment for the UK Green Investment Bank and I’m confident that there will be more to come.” Northern Ireland’s Energy Minister Arlene Foster added: “The Evermore plant will make an important contribution towards Northern Ireland’s 2020 renewable energy targets. “It is a wonderful example of local, national and international co-operation and I am particularly pleased to note that this is the first Northern Ireland project to secure funding from the Green Investment Bank.” The investment comes from the UK Waste Resources & Energy Fund (UKWREI), managed by investment management company Foresight, in which the GIB is the cornerstone investor. L aunched in November 2012 , the Green Investment Bank was given £3.8 billion of funding from the UK Government to support environmentally-friendly projects that cannot obtain sufficient funding from the markets. The GIB provides investment for renewable and low-carbon technologies such as offshore wind, energy from waste, non-domestic energy efficiency as well as biofuels for transport, biomass power, carbon capture and storage, marine energy and renewable heat projects. ‘Temporary solution’ Despite the GIB investment, Secretary of State for Energy Security Edward Davey has previously told the BBC that biomass was a temporary solution to meet climate targets while renewable energy systems were being developed. Indeed, government recently announced that grants for existing biomass plants are being capped at 400 megawatts (MW), and that there will be no renewable heat incentive (RHI) tariffs for new biomass plants. “Making electricity from biomass based on imported wood is not a long-term answer to our energy needs – I am quite clear about that”, he said. Biomass ‘dirtier than coal’ Biomass has been a controversial choice of renewable energy, with a joint report by the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB), Friends of the Earth and Greenpeace, titled ‘ Dirtier than Coal ‘ , suggesting that biomass derived from virgin wood may be more polluting than coal. Indeed, the government’s own statistics suggest that burning whole trees can result in 49 per cent more emissions than burning coal. Harry Huyton, RSPB Head of Climate Policy, explained: “When trees are burnt in power stations, CO2 [carbon dioxide] comes out of the chimney, just like it does when you burn coal. The difference is that the wood is less energy dense and is wetter than coal, so it takes a lot more energy to harvest, transport, process, and finally burn it. “Government has justified burning trees in power stations by claiming the chimney emissions are offset by the carbon that the forest takes in when it regrows after being harvested, but this is misleading. It can take decades, if not centuries, for the trees to recapture that carbon, leaving us with more emissions in the atmosphere now – when we least need it.” Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Investment, investments, London, News, Property, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on GIB Invests £20 Million In Biomass