TSI
Special UN Report: Biofuels Impact Food Prices and Availability
A new report from the High Level Panel of Experts on Food Security and Nutrition (HLPE) out of Rome, for the United Nations, implicates biofuels as a cause of high food prices. The June 2013 report, released today, is titled, “Biofuels and food security” (PDF) . This comprehensive document includes many interesting graphics and it attempts to cover all aspects of biofuels production. Every-so-often I catch a headline or tweet from biofuels interest groups or lobbyists who periodically promote the story that biofuels do not contribute to high food prices. This document clearly states that they do. While the ripple effect of the production and consumption of biofuels is far-reaching and can even account for some increased income for small-shareholder farmers, they are being promoted especially by corporate agricultural interests. Just this week DuPont received much feel-good publicity in promoting their food, agriculture and alternative energy “innovation center” in Johnston, Iowa, where their Pioneer Hi-Bred business unit is located. What was (at least part of) the hoopla really about? Making cellulosic ethanol out of corn stover. Taxpayers are on the hook for funding second generation biofuels, by the way, and cellulosic ethanol from corn stover qualifies. Follow the money. Currently, in the EU, biofuels policies are being rewritten, and the biofuels industry there, just like it does here, is lobbying hard against new proposals before the Parliament and Council to limit the use of food crops for biofuels. Here are a few chosen, key statements from the United Nation’s report: 1. In the last few years (since 2004) of short-term commodity food price increase, biofuels did play an important role. 2. All crops compete for the same land or water, labour, capital, inputs and investment and there are no current magic non-food crops that can ensure more harmonious biofuel production on marginal lands. Therefore, non-food/feedcrops should be assessed with the same rigour as food/feedcrops for their direct and indirect food security impacts. 3. In the case of the US, the impact on food security is essentially through the global transmission of prices. 4. (O)n the technological frontier for biofuels, few … countries have the resources to move forward to second-generation biofuels, given the often proprietary nature of this technology, the elevated capital investments required, and the high demands that second-generation technologies make on infrastructure, logistics and human capital. 5. (I)ndustrial advances can take place more quickly than agronomic advances needed to lower feedstock costs of both conventional and advanced biofuels. 6. Given the increasing price of fossil fuels and more efficient production, biofuels, or at least some of them, will be competitive even without public support. Increasingly it will be the market rather than policies that will drive the development of the sector. 7. Biofuel development has both global and local effects, positive and negative, short and long term. Many of these effects take the form of increased competition, for food, for land, for water. There are links between biofuels and food security. Therefore biofuel policies have to integrate food security as a major concern. Included was a good summary of how corn ethanol in the U.S. has impacted other commodities: The US has historically been both the world’s leading producer and exporter of corn, responsible for as much as 50 percent of world trade. The share of US corn production directed to ethanol increased in one decade from less than 10 percent to over 40 percent in the 2010/11 crop year, and remained at that high level in 2011/2012. Not only did the US exports and share in international corn trade decline as a result, but a significant part of the expansion of corn production in the US came at the expense of other major global crops, including soybeans. This was seen to have two effects: an increase in the price of corn and of its close substitutes like wheat on world markets, and a stimulation of food and feed production in other regions of the world, at the same time as major quantities of corn were subtracted from the feed market. This next chart shows us how policy of individual nations affects trade and consumption of biofuels. I also wanted to include the chart from the report with EROI (net energy return on investments) values from various feedstocks, but when I looked at their numbers, they looked quite “off” to me, so I am not including it here. Unfortunately, EROI numbers, while important, fluctuate wildly and are difficult to obtain and keep current, I suppose. The report lists the environmental sustainability concerns of biofuels, one of my own major concerns, below. 1. Lifecycle GHG emmisions. 2. Soil quality. 3. Harvest levels of wood resources. 4. Emissions of non-GHG air pollutants, including air toxics. 5. Water use and efficiency. 6. Water quality. 7. Biological diversity in the landscape. 8. Land use and land-use change related to bioenergy feedstock production. Certainly, here in the U.S., we have seen large negative impacts on all of the items on this list, making a project such as corn ethanol production insanely unsustainable and destructive to our environment in its current policy form. …………………………………………………………………….. NOTE: A special thanks to ActionAid for alerting me to this report. Continue reading
USDA’s Farmland Price Update Report (August 2013)
By K. McDonald on August 5th, 2013 The USDA comes out with an annual farmland price report every August. The newly issued report summarizes farmland price changes since a year ago. Here are this year’s report highlights: ● The United States farm real estate value, a measurement of the value of all land and buildings on farms, averaged $2,900 per acre for 2013, up 9.4 percent from revised 2012 values. ● Regional changes in the average value of farm real estate ranged from a 23.1 percent increase in the Northern Plains region to no change in the Southeast region. ● The highest farm real estate values were in the Cornbelt region at $6,400 per acre. ● The Mountain region had the lowest farm real estate value at $1,020 per acre. ● The United States cropland value increased by $460 per acre (13.0 percent) to $4,000 per acre. ● In the Northern Plains and Corn Belt regions, the average cropland value increased 25.0 and 16.1 percent, respectively, from the previous year. ● In the Southeast region, cropland values decreased by 2.8 percent. ● The United States pasture value increased to $1,200 per acre, or 4.3 percent above 2012. ● The Southeast region had the largest percentage decrease in pasture value, 1.5 percent below 2012. ● The Northern Plains had the highest increase in pasture value, at 18.4 percent. (Click to enlarge) Note that separate maps like the above are included in the report for cropland and pastureland values. SOURCE: Land Values 2013 Summary (PDF) Continue reading
Want To Invest In Farmland? Join The Crowd
By ABBIE FENTRESS SWANSON Credit Abbie Fentress Swanson/Harvest Public Media Charles Polanco’s company allows investors to team up and invest in farmland. The new company Fquare is bringing crowd-sourcing to the increasingly lucrative market of investing in farmland. Here’s how it works: On the Fquare website, an investor can purchase a share of a farmer’s land. If enough investors pool their money to buy the whole parcel, they become the new landowners and the farmer becomes the tenant on the land. The farmer gets a three-, five- or seven-year lease to work the land, and the landowners make up to 6 percent annual interest for the length of the lease. When the lease is up, Fquare sells that same farm to a new group of investors. This month, Fquare hopes to fund its first farm. In a busy New York restaurant around the corner from where the company is based, I chatted with the company’s founder, Charles Polanco. He said buying farmland through Fquare was easy, akin to purchasing a share of a mom-and-pop pizza parlor. “That’s how simple it is. You’ll go in, and there will be a land available for $1 million, and 10 individual investors would join together and put [down] the capital to buy it,” he said. Polanco said once a farm is crowd-funded, investors could see returns on their land right away. “Because we work with lease-back arrangements, the farmer will continue to pay the interest. The difference here is that they’ll start paying it to the investors,” he said. “So our investors, as soon as they get into a deal, they’ll start receiving income from that specific farmland deal. When we sell the land, the investors look to also take advantage of the land’s appreciation value.” Most of the land Fquare is interested in selling to investors is located in the Midwest. Polanco said ideally, the parcels will be between 300 and 1,000 acres and will cost investors from $1-$3 million. One of the strategies the company is using to acquire the land is through partnering with farming co-ops. “Many of these co-ops, they have farmers that are over the age of 60 that are looking either to retire or are sick and they can’t work the farm. They look towards platforms like ours because of the fact that we are more focused on lease-back arrangements,” said Polanco. “Basically we go in and offer to buy that land and lease it back to one of the producers of the coop, which is very valuable to them.” Although there’s plenty of speculation about the farmland bubble bursting, Polanco doesn’t see that happening any time soon. “We’re always monitoring farmland prices and we feel that there could be correction, whether now or in the future,” he said. “But many investors are very interested in continuing to acquire this land. We feel that as a long-term investment, farmland values are going to increase.” Continue reading




