TSI
Have Farmland Values Seen Their Top?
Jeff Caldwell 08/16/2013 @ 2:21pmMultimedia Editor for Agriculture.com and Successful Farming magazine. Corn and soybeans aren’t worth as much as they were a year ago. That’s got some farmers staring down the barrel of a breakeven price for corn and soybeans that may not be attainable based on current prices for the crops and the inputs it will take to raise them. And much of the expense side of the equation adding up to that necessary price comprises farmland. Ask a lot of farmers about the prospect of lower land costs in the coming year or so and many see that as an almost laughable scenario. Land prices simply haven’t fallen even though current levels make it tough to yield a profit on corn and soybean acres. In other words, $4.25 casn corn and $300/acre land rent don’t mix very well. “Ha! They should go down, but will they? I don’t think so,” says William Bruere, who with his family operates Bruere Farms near Prole, Iowa. “Despite lower farm income and expectations of additional declines, farmland values surged further during the second quarter. Irrigated cropland values in the District jumped 25% from a year ago. Nonirrigated cropland values advanced 18% from the previous year, a slightly slower pace of growth than in the first quarter,” says Nathan Kauffman, economist with the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City in a report released this week. But, farmers say lower grain prices make up just one piece of the land price crunch. One other element lies outside the farm sector; as long as investors have reason to remain anxious about the general equities market, it’s enough to keep capital streaming into land. “Crop prices are not the only thing supporting land values, but is one of them. Cheap money in the form of low interest is another,” says Agriculture.com Farm Business Talk veteran advisor sw363535 . “Federal borrowing and dumping of cash into the economy has helped the stock market values as much as grains prices. “If land prices do not come back down with the grain prices, it is not a good omen for the rest of the economy. Some of the Value of farm land has been fear-driven…or at least lack-of-faith driven.” This movement in land comes despite widely documented lower farm incomes based on lower grain prices that Kauffman says have driven higher farm loan volume in recent months. “Lower farm income boosted operating loan demand and hindered loan repayment rates in the second quarter. According to survey respondents, operating loan demand rose to its highest level in more than two years,” he says of the Fed’s most recent survey of ag lenders. “Loan repayment rates improved modestly, but bankers expected repayment rates to fall in the future with weakening farm income.” History — not necessarily specific conditions right now — sides with sw363535 ‘s assertion about the need for land prices to slip. Farm Business Talk senior contributor and farmland investor rswfarms says based on almost 80 years of data in Iowa, a trend of return on land investment of 4% to 6% has remained intact. It’s fluctuated from as much as 15% to as little as 1%, he says, but it’s always circled back to that average range for a normal corn-soybean rotation. “Currently for Iowa cropland growing corn and soybeans, with average yields, a $14,000/acre land cost, and a corn and soybean cash price of $4.25 and $11.50, the ROI ratio is in the 3% to 3.5% range. This is on the low end of the 75-year average, so if all things stay the same for the 2013 crop year it would not surprise me to see maybe a 5% decline in values for the 2014 fiscal year to get back to the average ROI ratio of 4% to 6%,” rswfarms says. “Personally, I see land leveling out for the rest of 2013, with the total 2013 appreciation rate being around the 18% to 20% rate. In 2014, with again normal yields and prices at $4.25 corn and $11.50 soybeans, a 5% decline could be in the cards for the fiscal 2014 year. Could we see another mid-1980s farmland crash where Iowa farmland went from $5,000/acre down to $850/acre for the best 80+ CSR dirt? No, I don’t see that happening and I will back up my statement by betting a 12-pack of beer.” Some ag lenders agree that the time is nigh for a downturn in land prices. In his survey, Fed economist Kauffman says while many see more of a leveling-off in land values in the near term, the number of those seeing a trend lower is growing. And, his data confirm rswfarms ‘ idea that the slide won’t amount to much if it does reach fruition. “While most bankers expected farmland values to remain at current levels, an increasing number of respondents felt farmland values may have peaked. Compared with previous surveys, fewer bankers expected farmland values to keep rising. More bankers also expected farmland values to drop after harvest likely due, at least partially, to expectations of lower farm income,” Kauffman says. “Among bankers anticipating a decline, though, a majority estimated farmland values would fall less than 10 percent during the next year. Very few bankers expected that farmland prices would drop more than 10%.” But, will this all happen? Will land values proceed to turn lower in the near future? Though the numbers indicate they should and will, farmers say they have little reason to believe they will see lower values and rents in the next year. “I’m willing to bet that any good land for sale would bring prices right around what we’ve seen in the past couple of years. That is, I don’t have any reason to expect a decline in value in the near future,” says Farm Business Talk veteran advisor Jim Meade / Iowa City . “The county sure doesn’t think so; my taxes have gone up again.” Continue reading
Despite Drop in Commodity Prices, Farmland Values Rise
By PAUL SULLIVAN Published: August 16, 2013 DAN LINDSTROM remembers looking at a piece of Nebraska farmland six or seven years ago that cost $3,300 an acre. Raised on a farm, he ran the numbers with his brother who is farming the family land and concluded that it was too expensive. He figured that with a 2 to 3 percent return, it made more sense to put the money into a dividend-paying stock and have his brother lease additional land. A few weeks ago, Mr. Lindstrom said similar land sold for nearly $11,000 an acre. This is a common story across the farm belt. In Indiana, William C. Ade, who made a fortune in oil and gas exploration in Asia, said he stopped adding to his 1,000 acres when the price passed $5,000 an acre. “Right now it’s at auction as high as $12,000 an acre,” he said of land to grow corn and soybeans in northwest Indiana. “A poor plot of land went for $8,000.” Mr. Lindstrom, who is a financial adviser at UBS Wealth Management in Omaha, and Mr. Ade, a member of the investment club Tiger 21, are among investors who say they believe farmland could be headed for a serious drop in values, if not a full-on crash. Of course, many of them have been thinking that for years. The traditional view of farmland, from the farmer to the agricultural economist to the investment adviser, is, as Mr. Ade put it, “an inflation-proof bond.” (“No one is going to steal it,” he said. “No one is going to default on it. If inflation goes up, it will still be there.”) After the financial collapse of 2008, most forms of real estate were shunned. But not farmland. Prices shot up, driven by rising commodity prices from global demand, low interest rates in the United States and high auction prices begetting higher prices. Now commodity prices have fallen. Corn has gone to about $4.60 a bushel this week from over $8 a bushel last year. Soybeans have fallen to about $12.60 a bushel from over $17. Yet the value of farmland for row crops has continued to rise. “We’re kind of at an inflection point,” said Brent Gloy, a professor of agricultural economics at Purdue University. “We’ve had five years of spectacular profitability that was somewhat unanticipated. The U.S.D.A. was forecasting much lower than this, so it surprised people.” Yet there are still reasons to think that there will be buyers for land who will hold on to it for decades to come. A report released by U.S. Trust highlighted the graying of America’s farmers and their need to sell or lease their land as they age. “Can land go up and down?” asked John Taylor, national farm and ranch executive for U.S. Trust, which manages 900 farms for investors. “Sure. But I’ve never seen land go to zero. And with world demand, there is no vacancy factor on good U.S. farmland.” All of this raises the issue of whether it is time to sell. Brian C. Duke, vice president for Northern Trust, said that even with the run-up in prices for commodities, the annual return of farmland remains about 3 percent. Since 2000, the value of land in Illinois, for example, has increased 207 percent. For an investment comparison, The Dow Jones industrial average went up 42 percent in that period. Triple-digit appreciation has a way of luring new investors. More experienced investors said that appreciation isn’t the goal: to realize it you have to sell the land. “The capital gain is nice, ” said Albert Kirchner, who is known as Bud and owned a manufacturing company. “We don’t look at the capital gain. We look at it from a productivity standpoint.” Mr. Kirchner owns 6,000 acres of corn and soybean land in Illinois, an 8,000-acre cattle ranch in Montana and 1,200 acres of timberland in Florida. But his benchmark since he started investing in land after World War II has remained a 4 percent annual return. At that number and using Agriculture Department estimates that the average farmland value in Illinois is $7,800, Mr. Kirchner’s land would be worth $46.8 million, with an annual return of $1,872,000. But for the person who has bought land recently at auction, getting even 4 percent becomes more challenging. At $12,000 an acre, a 4 percent return is $480. Kevin Casner, who farms 2,400 acres in Carrollton, Mo., with his son Adam, said the rents in his area ranged from $150 to $450 an acre. (Those rents were negotiated before commodity prices started to fall, and will presumably drop.) But for the person who has bought land recently at auction, getting even 4 percent becomes more challenging. At $12,000 an acre, a 4 percent return is $480. Kevin Casner, who farms 2,400 acres in Carrollton, Mo., with his son Adam, said the rents in his area ranged from $150 to $450 an acre. (Those rents were negotiated before commodity prices started to fall, and will presumably drop.) A landlord can squeeze a farmer only so far on rent. Mr. Lindstrom said that an acre of his family farm was producing 175 bushels of corn, which equals a little more than $740 at $4.25 a bushel. But a farmer has some pretty hefty fixed costs. He said that, per acre, seed is $100, nitrogen is $100, dry fertilizer is $100, taxes are $50, insecticide is $30, chemicals are $50, and cash rent is $300 on average. That is $680 without factoring in the cost of equipment and labor. There is no room to increase the rent in this example by $180 more an acre. This balance between commodity prices and land values and rents can change. It is why all land investors need to have a long enough time frame. “If you’re wanting to park money for five years, farmland is really not what you should be investing in,” Mr. Duke said. “You need to have that longer-term approach.” Many farmers and investors fear the past decade could be too much of a good thing. “In real terms the gain we’ve seen in farmland values over the last 10 years are greater than those we saw in the 1970s,” said Professor Gloy of Purdue. In the early 1980s, farmland prices crashed when interest rates went up and farmers could not continue to borrow to finance their operations. The two things that could set off a decline are a further drop in commodity prices and higher interest rates. Matt Ward, one of the owners of Premier Grain Farms in Walker, Iowa, said that a drop of $2 a bushel in the price of corn translated to a loss of about $400 an acre. If all 15,000 acres he farms were planted evenly, that would translate into $6 million less in revenue than the land produced last year. Investors who have sharecropping agreements that designate a split in the harvest between farmer and owner will see their return reduced immediately. Those who have cash leases are likely to have to negotiate lower rents when the lease is renewed. Another option for an investor has been a variable cash lease. The owner would accept a lower cash rent up front and negotiate an additional payment if the price of the commodity or the yield was higher. There is now less chance of upside potential. As for interest rates, the fear is that they will rise and the value of land will fall. Mr. Lindstrom, the farm owner who works for UBS, said there was no way to finance land at today’s rates of 5 percent and make money. Cash buyers, he said, are at risk of losing their principal. “Could the land go from $10,000 to $15,000 an acre?” he said. “Sure, but not today and not with corn at $4.25. I’d be surprised if we don’t go from $10,000 to $8,000 or $7,000. Land has tripled in the last five to six years.” Still, this was the man who passed on buying land at $3,300 an acre because he thought it was overpriced. “We just tried to buy more ground and were willing to go to $7,500 an acre,” Mr. Lindstrom said. “It went for $10,500. My instincts tell me we’ll buy that ground, and we’ll buy it cheaper.” Continue reading
Fed: Farm Land Values Boom Shows Signs Of Slowing
Aug. 17, 2013 Written by Christopher Doering Gannett Washington Bureau WASHINGTON — Farmland values in the Midwest were stable during the second quarter of 2013, marking the first time they have failed to rise in four years, the Federal Reserve Bank said as bankers hinted the boom of the past few years may be coming to an end. The Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago said the average dollar value of “good” farmland across Iowa was flat for the April 1 to July 1 period. Despite the quarter, land values in the country’s largest corn and soybean producing state have jumped 18 percent since July 1, 2012 — reflecting the strong farm economy and booming demand for productive land. Similar to Iowa, land prices across other states covered by the Federal Reserve branch have seen sharp gains over the last year, but they posted mixed results during the second quarter. Land values in Indiana and Wisconsin rose 5 percent and 1 percent, respectively, but Illinois and Michigan had small decreases. Overall, the five-state region was unchanged during the second quarter with prices climbing 17 percent from a year ago. The last time farmland prices failed to rise was in the third quarter of 2009. “While the farmland values on a year-over-year basis still appeared to be soaring, changes in farmland values on a quarterly basis may be presaging shifts in the year-over-year pattern in the latter half of 2013,” said David Oppedahl, a business economist at the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago. “Survey respondents reinforced this conclusion with their assessments that agricultural land values were likely to be flat in the third quarter of 2013.” The survey was compiled with input from 211 agricultural bankers, with 86 percent of respondents expecting stable land values through the end of September. One banker cautioned that land values would go down as grain prices fall. In recent years, record-high prices for corn, soybeans, wheat and other commodities have left growers flush with cash to purchase more land. And what the farmers don’t pay for out of their own pockets, historically low interest rates provided them with easy and cheap access to money to close the deal. But that appears to be changing. The Federal Reserve branch said interest rates on farm loans during the second quarter moved up for the first time since early 2011. And this week, the U.S. Agriculture Department estimated corn prices would average $4.90 a bushel this year, compared to $6.95 a bushel in 2012, with soybeans forecast to drop to $11.35 a bushel from $14.40. “The anticipation of lower crop revenues – especially when combined with potentially rising interest rates on farm loans – portended softness in future farmland values,” Oppedahl said. In Iowa, where rich soil, favorable weather and ethanol and livestock production help foster demand for limited growing space, farmland values have nearly doubled since 2009. Some prime real estate has sold for more than $20,000 an acre. An acre of farmland that a decade ago sold for an average of $2,275 went for about $8,300 in 2012, according to Mike Duffy, an economist at Iowa State University who watches land prices. Values have risen every year since 2000, with the exception of 2009 when they dropped 2.2 percent. Kyle Hansen, a real estate agent at Hertz Farm Management in Nevada, Iowa, said the drop in commodity prices – coupled with a cool, wet spring followed by a dry summer – has not left many farmers in a buying mood. “Some (farmers) look at what their income is going to be potentially this year or the following years when they are deciding whether they should be purchasing or not,” said Hansen. “That, too, will somewhat tame the aggressiveness of bidders at auctions. It’s somewhat of a flat market.” Hansen said farmers will probably wait until after the harvest when more is known about the output from this year’s crop and the resulting impact on commodity prices before deciding whether to resume buying land. If commodity prices are steady or higher, land values could post a “minimal increase,” he said, but if “commodity prices stay low we could see a retraction of land values.” Continue reading




