Taylor Scott International
Should You Buy Farmland? Or Bonds? Or Oil? No!
This story appears in the June 24, 2013 issue of Forbes. Two areas investors should pare back on are bonds and farmland. And regarding energy, be extremely careful. Bonds have been overpriced since 2008, but that doesn’t mean the bubble won’t eventually burst. Debt instruments have already taken a hit as the Federal Reserve hints that it will be scaling back its vacuuming of Treasurys and mortgage-backed bonds. Unless you have to do the bond dance (the only buyers, other than speculators, of long-term government paper are financial institutions that must have such securities for regulatory reasons)–don’t! Municipal bonds are in a different universe from corporates and Treasurys. Here the big risk is solvency. Unless you are an expert or have an advisor who is, go for well-diversified muni-bond funds with durations of under five years. Undermining the integrity of the dollar is similar to introducing a virus into your computer: It corrupts the information. In the economy an unstable dollar undermines the integrity of prices. Hard assets go up when the dollar is weakened, as people seek to preserve what they have. Traditional, productive investments are hurt. In the inflationary 1970s the price of farmland boomed. Same with agricultural commodities. Farmers leveraged to get more and more land. When inflation was conquered in the early 1980s, this Fed-created boom collapsed. Agricultural America went into a depression. A couple of years ago in Nebraska I warned against the rapid rise in the price of farmland since the early 2000s. I was assured that farmers had vivid memories of what had happened in the 1970s and would not overborrow to make purchases. I’m not so sure this is the case today. It certainly isn’t with Wall Street , where institutions and individual investors are treating farmland as a great asset class, and many are borrowing to purchase it. Caveat emptor! Energy also has been given an artificial boost by the shaky dollar for the past decade. Commodity inflation, including oil, has for the moment sharply subsided because the Fed has been sterilizing most of the money it’s been printing by borrowing it back from banks. There’s no way to know how much more of a downside there is, but unless you are farsighted and nimble, you should be extremely cautious with energy investments. If you’re overweighted in energy, cut back for now. To repeat, the Fed may give commodities, bonds and farmland a new round of bubble life, but if you’re a long-term investor, don’t get sucked in. Continue reading
GCC Investors Eye African Farmland
22 April 2013, 9:26 GMT | By Paul Melly Africa’s fertile soil can provide food security and investment opportunities In the capital-rich countries of the GCC, the chronic shortage of rainfall limits the prospects for food production. On the other hand, the African continent has vast agricultural potential but suffers from a shortage of investment. The complementarity of interests between the Gulf and its economic partners south of the Sahara seems clear, and has been recognised since the late 1990s as governments on both sides explore the scope for deals that could make African land available to Arab investors. However, translating this vision into a mutually beneficial reality has proved a complex challenge. For GCC states, the key concern has been to ensure security of food supply. Populations in the GCC states are growing fast and traditional local oasis agriculture cannot satisfy the consumption demands of booming societies in the modern era. GCC constraints To mitigate the problem, Gulf governments have encouraged domestic irrigated production. But the potential for this practice is limited by environmental and financial constraints. Natural aquifers in the region are becoming depleted, while using desalinated water is hugely expensive. The method might be viable for some high-value horticultural crops, but makes little sense for cereals. Saudi Arabia eventually concluded that the large-scale irrigated production of wheat was not a sensible use of limited and highly subsidised water supplies, and the practice is now being phased out. High oil prices have enabled GCC states to maintain security of food supply despite rising world prices. But most have felt uncomfortable relying so heavily on the open world market. Over the past 15 years they have explored the scope to invest in land in other regions that have more reliable agricultural potential. But it has not always been possible to buy or lease land in countries that are major global grain exporters; big rice producers such as Thailand, for example, impose tight restrictions. This has led GCC governments to look to Africa, where fertile land and rainfall are in more ample supply than on the Arabian peninsula. Since the 1990s, there has been a steady trickle of announcements about major investments in the continent’s land, often from Saudi Arabia. In 2009, the Jenat consortium of Saudi agricultural firms announced plans for a $40m investment in food production in Sudan and Ethiopia, while another Saudi group, Hadco, is reported to have acquired 25,000 hectares of Sudanese cropland. Last year, Sheikh Mohammed al-Amoudi’s Saudi Star group launched a programme to develop 500,000 hectares of land in Ethiopia, and a small area of this is already in production. Governments have also been important actors in this process. Qatar agreed a deal to take over large tracts of the Tana River delta in Kenya, in return for building a new port at Lamu. The Abu Dhabi Fund for Development is said to be funding a 28,000-hectare project in Sudan to grow alfalfa, maize, beans and potatoes for export to the UAE. Riyadh leads Once again it is Saudi Arabia that has led the field, with government support for agricultural partnerships with Africa, notably through the state’s King Abdullah Initiative for Saudi Agricultural Investment Abroad (KAISAIA). In 2012, the kingdom’s Agriculture Minister, Fahd Balghunaim, announced that the task of agricultural investment abroad would be transferred to a KAISAIA offshoot, the Saudi Company for Agricultural Investment and Animal Production (SCAIAP). The firm has capital of SR3bn ($800m), although it is not thought to have disbursed funds yet. Many of the announced GCC agricultural investments have never been implemented, or even started, on the ground in Africa, says Eckhart Woertz, author of Oil for Food: The Global Food Crisis and the Middle East, a new book examining these issues. “There is a huge discrepancy between amounts projected and amounts actually implemented,” he says. Moreover, he points out that concrete schemes have been confined to a relatively small number of countries. “Sudan is certainly top of the list, followed by Ethiopia, Tanzania, West Africa, Senegal and Mali,” he says. “Sudan is the most popular country for announcements, but most of the projects have either not started or, if they have started, are at a very early stage of implementation.” There are several reasons for the gap between ambition and reality. Other than livestock from the Horn of Africa, GCC countries have little track record of importing food from the continent. The GCC’s plans to invest in sub-Saharan agriculture as a source of food crops for home markets have been hindered by the fact that many of the targeted African countries have a tropical climate that is not well suited to the cultivation of some of the products most heavily consumed in the Arab world, such as wheat and barley. These temperate-climate cereals are mainly imported from Canada, the US, Australia, Russia, Ukraine and EU states such as France. Rice is widely grown in Africa and is a crop that is also heavily consumed in the GCC. At present, most Gulf imports of basmati rice come from Pakistan and India, although Arab investors have now developed some pilot projects in Senegal and Mali for export to the Gulf. Local challenges A further major hurdle is that local social and political conditions are not always welcoming. Land-lease agreements between Gulf investors or governments and central governments in sub-Saharan Africa are often seen as attempted land grabs by wealthy outsiders. These deals can be hugely controversial in countries that are poor and where much of the indigenous local population is undernourished. They can spark protests among local populations, local and international media, and non-governmental organisations. Woertz cites the example of Qatar’s agreement with Kenya to take over land in the Tana River valley. “The locals started complaining; there was a lot of resistance by land groups,” he says. “Originally, the scheme was tied to the construction of a port at Lamu, but now the Chinese have got the contract to build the port.” Land deals with Gulf investors – and other outsiders, including the Koreans – have provoked fears that existing local users such as pastoralists or smallholders will be pushed out to make way for big, foreign commercial investors. Still, Woertz says Arab investors have become more sensitive to these issues. “There is a certain readiness to take these things into consideration,” he says. “So, perhaps you may see other types of projects taking place: to share equity or have outgrower schemes.” Gulf governments and investors have held talks with the UN’s Food & Agriculture Organisation (FAO), which could act as an honest broker in identifying opportunities for agricultural partnerships between the GCC and Africa that would respect the interests of communities on both sides. But the realisation of such an approach presents complex challenges. Woertz points out that Saudi Arabia’s strategic goal remains the production of food for its domestic consumption. Indeed, those Saudi agricultural firms that have been looking at investment in Africa expect to enjoy substantial subsidies from the kingdom’s authorities. This is because their role would be to produce food to replace the output of the domestic cereals programme that is now being wound up for environmental reasons. The cereals scheme was massively subsidised, says Woertz. “The direct costs of subsidies for the Saudi wheat program were $85bn between 1984 and 2000. This was equivalent to 18 per cent of Saudi Arabia’s $485bn in oil revenues during that period.” Rethinking strategy Another option is to treat African agriculture as essentially an investment; a business proposition focused on the world market rather than a means of satisfying Gulf demand for food imports. This is a strategy being pursued by Hassad Foods, an arm of Qatar Holding, which is part of the emirate’s sovereign wealth fund, Qatar Investment Authority. Hassad’s publicity material says: “While all investments are there to generate profits, they also exist to fulfil certain needs to support the food security programme when required.” But such an approach can pose tough challenges for GCC investors, who mostly lack experience in producing or marketing tropical cash crops and risk finding themselves in direct competition with long-established sub-Saharan and Western players. They will often need to recruit foreign sector specialists to actually establish and run the projects for them. Even so, some have taken on the challenge. In 2011, Saudi-based Menafea Holdings revealed plans to invest $125m in a new pineapple farm and processing plant in Zambia. The GCC is short on food, but rich in cash. African nations are fertile and need money. As ties between the Gulf and Africa strengthen, investment in agriculture is likely to grow. Continue reading
Capturing the plight of Syria’s refugees
Capturing the plight of Syria’s refugees Sarah Young / 23 June 2013 From an elderly woman forced to watch the murder of her husband, to the young man who suddenly finds himself a father of three — a new photography exhibition opening in Dubai this week hopes to open people’s eyes to the heartbreaking effects of civil war on the Syrian people. Victims of War, an exhibition featuring the work of Hermoine Macura, a Dubai-based Australian journalist who has worked in the Middle East for 12 years, will be on display at Pro Art Gallery from June 25. Macura said the non-political and non-governmental project, with its focus on highlighting humanitarian crises and suffering in Syria, was the hardest and most heart-breaking work she had done in the Middle East. The photos were taken in late December last year and early January, mainly at the Zaatari refugee camp in Jordan, near the town of Masraq about 30 to 50 kilometres from Syria, where thousands of refugees were arriving daily, she said. “Children with special needs, people in wheelchairs, people having to be carried over the border, elderly…like a swarm through the sandstorms…imagine a sandstorm in Dubai times ten. You could barely see. “Some women were giving birth on the border with no medical care.” But what troubled her the most were the sexual and gender-based crimes against women. “Some women were tortured and raped with animals and rodents. Girls as young as 10, 11, 12 raped, tortured and mutilated. I have never seen such extreme cases of torture like this in the Middle East, even when I was in Iraq. Humanitarian organisations had to bring in psychologists and counsellors to deal with the trauma, she said. “The cultural shame and embarrassment attracted to (rape) made it very difficult for people to seek medical treatment…many were suffering in silence. “As an outsider it was just shocking. We don’t get to see how people really suffer. We get desensitised, and there’s nothing focused on highlighting this. It took a long time to digest what she had seen. “Every single person stays in my eyes, heart and mind. “When you see things like this, it makes you more sensitive to choosing diplomatic solutions over war…everyone is so quick to take that option (of war), especially when you live in priviledged societies where you’re safe and secure, but they don’t realise the consequences, the damage on generations of people and how it affects society as a whole. While those living in the UAE were blessed, people living in other parts of the Arab world were not. “I really don’t know what will happen to them. If you look at Iraq before the Gulf War, it was a very rich country, and if you go there now the Iraqi people are in poverty. A lot of women are turning to prostitution.” Eighty per cent of the refugees she saw were women and children. “In any situation of lawlessness, the women and children are going to suffer the most. “When you break the woman you break the society. She’s raising the children, holding everyone and the community together.” While she saw very few men, she could vividly recall one who had adopted the children of his two brothers who had been killed, and taken them across the border. “This was a single, unmarried man who was now a father of three children at 25 years old. He took these kids across the border and is now in a camp trying to plan or work out how do you move on from this.” Another face which stuck with her was that of a woman in her 80s. “Gangs came to her house. They killed her husband and burnt her house to the ground in front of her. She has nothing. She came across that border by herself. It was unusual to see elderly people being attacked in the Middle East, she said. “People work their whole lives for their home. Now she’s got nothing. She said ‘I can’t stay here because this is not my country. But there’s nothing for me at home either. I don’t know what to do’. “My camera man had to stop shooting because he was crying. It was so, so sad.” The two images that stuck with her the most, though, were of children. The first is of three disabled boys, standing in a desert storm trying to close their jackets with what was left of their arms. “They were like scarecrows on the rocks. To see young lives just blowing or withering in the wind…it was very disturbing. “This was the first project where I got to see how children and people with special needs suffered…there were not enough wheelchairs, kids had to sit on the floor or in a makeshift box with wheels.” The other image was of a little girl, about nine, outside a medical facility waiting for treatment. “It was the determination in her face…I felt that was a ray of hope. I could feel the spirit of the Syrian people in that young girl…who had come by herself, and was still holding it together. I just hope when people see these images they can see the humanitarian crisis, (but also) the people — that there is hope too, not just suffering.” The UN’s refugee agency UNHCR, medical staff, and volunteer camp workers, were doing an “amazing job”. “(UNHCR have) poured $1 million into refugee camps in Lebanon, Jordan and Turkey. “Compared to what the Palestinians had to endure in the camps in Lebanon, this is really good. The shelters and tents are like little villages, housing more than 100,000 people. She said she was impressed with the high donations being made by Saudi Arabia and the UAE, even though the countries did not shout about it. Expert doctors also flew in every ten days from the Gulf states and some children were flown to GCC countries for specialised surgery, she said. “So in that darkness, there was some hope that came to light…some kids were born with a club foot but were so poor, or lived in such remote parts, they had never been able to be treated. And now they could be.” According to the UNHCR website, more than 1.6 million Syrian refugees are being hosted in foreign countries, with the majority in Lebanon and Jordan — and more than one million of those arrived in the first five months of 2013 alone. Women and children make up three-quarters of the refugee population. If current trends persisted, it could be expected that more than three million Syrians would have left their country by the end of this year, the website said. The exhibition will be going to Qatar and New York with all profits being donated to humanitarian organisations such as UNHCR. It opens at 7pm on June 25 and runs until July 15, at Pro Art Gallery in the Palm Strip Shopping Mall on Jumeirah Beach Road, Jumeirah 1. See www.victimsofwar.ae . sarah@khaleejtimes.com Continue reading




