Taylor Scott International

Biomass: Head To Head Debating Pros And Cons

Is biomass a viable part of the future energy mix, or is it part of the carbon emissions problem? Eoin Redahan asked two industry experts. Stewart Boyle (SB) runs the consultancy arm of South East Wood Fuels Duncan Law (DL) represents Biofuelwatch, an NGO that raises awareness of the negative impacts of industrial biofuels and bioenergy. Stewart Boyle The pro biomass perspective – SB I spent 18 months on research into the potential and reality of bio-energy in the UK. Its advantages are real, in that it provides versatility (offering heating, cooling, power generation, transport fuels and bio-chemicals), reliability (no problems with intermittency), and is sustainable and cost-effective. It could provide 10–20% of our energy by 2030–2040 – three times the output of nuclear power. Bio-energy is a critical renewable option in allowing the clear transition to lowcarbon hybrid vehicles, de-carbonising power and shifting to green gas. To achieve its potential we need a significant effort to educate, show how it offers an integrated energy solution, and argue head-on the bad science arguments being used against it. From a support position five years ago, many environmental NGOs now oppose biofuels, pure biopower and co-firing. One NGO, Biofuelwatch, says bio-energy leads to forest destruction – witness its attitudes on palm oil and kernels for biofuels – and suggests that Drax (the UK’s largest power station, which co-fires biomass) mostly uses old growth forest from North America. This is utter tosh and the Drax team should be applauded, not criticised, for its cradle-to-grave sustainability system. I spent a big chunk of my earlier life working for several NGOs. However, I think many are biased, use bad science and have lost the plot on bio-energy. Duncan Law The anti biomass perspective – DL Under the guise of renewable energy and carbon saving, burning wood in power stations is a massive growth industry in the UK right now. Huge old coal power stations such as Drax are getting UK Government subsidies to burn millions of tonnes of imported wood at 37% efficiency, but can only use good quality wood with low bark content – not pure forest wastes. Burning wood emits even more carbon than burning coal for a given amount of energy generated (especially when whole trees are used). Forests take up to a century to absorb as much CO2 as is emitted when they are burned. So emissions will actually rise. The DECC now acknowledges that burning biomass in dedicated power stations offers poor-value carbon savings compared with wind power or even gas. Yet they offer huge subsidies. Current UK biomass burning plans are projected to demand nearly the entire global biomass trade by 2025. Most of it currently comes from the USA and Canada where biodiverse, old-growth forests are being clear felled and replaced with monoculture tree plantations. Biomass also produces more small particulate pollution than coal, which can have grave public health impacts. Minister Ed Davey, UK Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change, said, ‘Making electricity from biomass based on imported wood is not a long-term answer to our energy needs – I am quite clear about that’. Biomass is not an answer. It pollutes, is costly, inefficient, does not contribute to UK energy security, damages biodiversity and forests, and makes climate change worse. SL: I disagree with virtually all of Duncan’s comments on bioenergy. Take the carbon debt issue – the supposed scientific basis of much NGO opposition. Duncan says, ‘Forests take up to a century to absorb as much CO2 as is emitted when they are burned’. In my opinion, this is misleading. While cutting and then replacing a single tree or small stand of trees will take some time for the CO2 to be absorbed, guess what? Foresters know that. A well-managed forest has a wide range of trees – some mature and ready for felling, others in mid-growth and absorbing lots of CO2, plus newly planted trees. When DECC researchers looked at the issue, they concluded, ‘Providing forest stands are re-established as soon as they are clear-felled, overall carbon stocks in the forest are not reduced [no carbon debt is incurred]. Rather, a constant carbon stock is maintained over time.’ Using low-quality wood materials that have no competing uses, Drax clearly demonstrates substantial carbon savings of well over 70%. That Drax ‘mostly’ uses wood from clear-felled old growth forests is simply not true. Duncan references this from a single BBC radio programme, but any independent audit of Drax’s biomass materials would refute the suggestion. No one argues that co-firing is the end game. Other technologies are coming fast. It does, however, offer reliable, lower-cost carbon reductions quickly to gain momentum and investment into this and second-generation technologies. Arguing for perfection now in bio-energy will kill off key solutions to our climate crisis and invite in shale gas, nuclear and extreme oil. DL: Biofuelwatch has been working for seven years on this issue. We follow the plot of the bioenergy industry closely. To counter just one of Stewart’s specific assertions – Drax bases its optimistic 70% carbon savings from biomass on using ‘forest wastes that would simply be burnt in the forest’ (Paul Taylor, Drax Director). Freedom of Information evidence shows they can only use wood from slow growing trees that have a low bark content. Drax is using pellets from whole trees. Dogwood Alliance (a forest protection network) has documented clear-felling of old-growth forest for the energy industry. Peer-reviewed evidence shows that rates of global forest cover loss in southeast USA are among the highest globally. Conversion to tree plantations causes huge emissions. All this equals carbon debt. The impossibility of real sustainability assessment in the biomass industry is documented in a Biofuelwatch report. Vast Government subsidies and the Green Investment Bank loan to Drax extend the coalburning life of this plant by years. And the biomass will increase, not reduce, its real carbon emissions. Biomass is the easy option for the Government and industry to avoid a supply crunch and keep the lights on by using existing technologies. The vast ambitions of the bio-energy industry disregard unintended consequences. It is set to expand in a way that is dangerous and unsustainable. Biofuelwatch opposes big bioenergy because the impacts are unacceptably dangerous, both in terms of current carbon emissions and damage to the planet’s life support systems. It is a distraction from rethinking our demand and our energy systems for a real low-carbon future. Both speakers referred to different sources to back up their statements. For a full list of sources, visit our blog: materialsworld.tumblr.com What do you think? Which of the two speakers convinced you most? Are there any other important issues that should be addressed? Email or tweet us your comments at: materials.world@iom3.org or @materialsworld or if you are logged in, comment below. Author : Eoin Redahan Materials World Magazine, 01 Sep 2013 – See more at: http://www.iom3.org/…h.GbKH9FL2.dpuf Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Investment, investments, News, Property, Shows, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Biomass: Head To Head Debating Pros And Cons

Rubber Study Group Looks for Sustainability Plan

By Huileng Tan SINGAPORE — The Singapore-based International Rubber Study Group is embarking on an ambitious initiative to draw up a plan for the industry, much like what the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil did in the tropical oil seed industry. Courtesy of Lekshmi Nair Senior economist and statistician Lekshmi Nair, of the International Rubber Study Group, says what is needed “is commitment from all players in the supply chain” to end up with a sustainability plan. An overwhelming 85% of rubber production comes from small growers. That has meant that the fragmented industry has never come together to agree on a common set of sustainability standards. Natural rubber is a major tropical cash crop valued at more than US$30 billion annually. It has a long history of being cultivated for commercial uses. A boom in the last decade sent prices to record highs and spurred rapid new plantings outside of the traditional producing countries of Thailand, Indonesia and Malaysia, which account for over two-thirds of the world’s natural rubber supply. With burgeoning demand from China fueling rapid planting in these new areas – such as Cambodia and Laos — environmentalists and scientists are increasingly voicing concern about the environmental impact of rubber plantations. While rubber trees are deemed to be green, because they absorb carbon, large tracts of planting will lead to habitat loss for birds, elephants, tigers and other wildlife in the region, and also disrupt water movement, they argue. Set up in 1944, the International Rubber Study Group is made up of more than 30-member governments, as well as producer groups and consumers such as tire companies. Now its members are trying to give it a new, important mission of trying to balance its commercial success while not being overly destructive of the environment. The Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil was formed in 2004 in response to pressure from social and environmental groups to develop global standards for the entire palm oil supply chain. Plantation firms, such as Sime Darby Bhd and IOI Corporation Bhd, with estates larger than the city-state of Singapore, were first to adopt the standards and now account for the bulk of 8.2 million tons of eco-friendly palm oil produced annually. A key figure at the rubber study group’s sustainable project is senior economist and statistician Lekshmi Nair.  She spoke to The Wall Street Journal about what the organization envisions for the industry. Excerpts follow: The Wall Street Journal : You are setting up a sustainable natural rubber action plan. Define sustainability. Lekshmi Nair: The definition of sustainability varies from different stakeholders, but, in general, sustainability means ensuring continuity of raw material so that it’s not disturbed. The mission of the sustainability initiative in rubber is to promote the economic, environmental and social sustainability in the production and use through dialogue and cooperation with all stakeholders along the supply chain. Now, there is an imbalance in that 85% of natural rubber production is coming straight from small growers while 70% of the consumers are from the tire sector. So we need commitment from both sides [in the form of a memorandum]. For the producers, natural rubber has the potential to generate a number of positive environmental benefits. Sustainability initiatives in rubber have positive impacts on the development policies of the producer economies. Promotion of sustainable production can enhance producers’ market entry and competitiveness in the growing new markets for sustainable products. For the consumers, the tire industry is by far the largest end-use market for natural rubber, with tire producers purchasing around 70% of total natural rubber placed on the global market. About 85% of natural rubber is produced by smallholders, whose decision to plant new trees and tap depends on opportunity cost. [Corporate Social Responsibility] is scaling up to include social as well as environment standards, with application of sustainability principles with regard to resource efficiency or purchase of raw materials [rubber]. So what we needed is commitment from all players in the supply chain to achieve objectives in this initiative in natural rubber. From the producer end, we have to take care of resource efficiency and the purchase of raw materials. This productivity in turn will ensure income for the small growers. For all major consumers, CSR is an issue. From the CSR point of view, the raw material that they are procuring must be shown to be sustainable, and one aspect of this is in its production. What are some of the sustainability criteria you are looking at? Other than improving productivity, we want to ensure natural rubber quality. Improving quality ensures enhancing productivity that certainly will increase income of predominantly small growers. If we looking at the emerging producing countries or African countries, you can see that the rubber they produce is filled with a lot of with impurities. In fact, you can say 50% is filled with sand or wood particles. Latex is collected in a cup attached to trees. So what small growers do is to collect the lumps and throw them to the ground, So contaminants will stick them. However, if small growers take some initiative to avoid these practices, they can avoid impurities at an early stage, which will save a lot of energy during processing. So it’s also beneficial from an environmental point of view. Bad quality rubber will require more energy for cleaning and will also produce more waste. Waste reduction can at start at the production stage. Natural rubber is known as a green product as the trees absorb carbon dioxide. What impact does large-scale cultivation of rubber as a cash crop have? Because of the demand for natural rubber, there is a lot of large-scale investment in emerging countries. One issue involves the use of forested versus degraded land. We encourage using degraded forest, and this initiative encourages this type of cultivation versus cutting down forested land. A comprehensive range of social issues, like land use shift, tenure rights, food security, are also within the? broader impact on large-scale investments. Also, when land is given for rubber cultivation, investors have to ensure food security for residents in the area first before they can cultivate a non-food crop like rubber. We need to ensure a balance between the two crops. First, we need to get commitment from all supply chain stakeholders so that the sustainability efforts become voluntary standards. Natural rubber is a commodity with a long history of being cultivated for profit. What took the industry so long to come up with these standards, which you are drawing up? Many of the established rubber growing countries do have initiatives and framework for enhancing small grower productivity through some form of sustainability efforts. But our project will involve multiple stakeholders, including governments and private individuals. At this stage, no civil society organizations [non-governmental organizations] are involved. We know there are some issues surrounding rubber, such as land rights and environmental issues. What is the state of the rubber industry now? Historically you’re looking at rubber as a colonial crop. It started as an organized plantation crop before government land ownership restrictions [to prevent individuals from accumulating too much land] saw it shift to being a small-holder crop. So that’s where the rubber is coming from now, and we need to reach out to these small growers. Other than CSR standards and image, what’s in it for consumers, like major tire makers and small holders? For commodities, there’s a boom and bust cycle. During the bust cycle, growers are withdrawing from this crop. But at the same time for consumers, they want need to keep the production line going, so they need to have an ensured quantity of rubber. Here, we need the consumers’ commitment to encourage small growers to stay with the cultivation of this crop. Sustainable prices are a concern for both producers and consumers. If the price is not sustainable, consumers may find it difficult to get their assured quantity from the producers because nobody can force the small growers to produce. They can do something else. Why not? There’s an opportunity for everybody and they are businessmen. What’s the next stage in the project? We hope to get all stakeholders commitment to this initiative [to sign a memorandum] by the next World Rubber Summit [likely in May of 2014 and held in Singapore] to get their commitment to certain standards. We hope to eventually get into a voluntary certification for sustainable natural rubber. Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Investment, investments, News, Property, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Rubber Study Group Looks for Sustainability Plan

Timber Rules

NANDHINI SUNDAR Timber in house design. The strength of timber is dependent on its usage and seasoning. But what sets it apart from other building materials is its beauty, says Nandhini Sundar Use of wood in housing is as old as dwellings, dating back to the very first hut that was built with tree branches and leaves. While history has seen many experiments with wood, where it featured as the main structural element, weaving in intricate geometrical concepts, incorporating arches and round shapes in timber frames, currently its use is more in aesthetics than functionality. Wood features as façade, on ceilings, walls, floors, furniture, and artefacts, meeting essentially the aesthetic requirements. Interestingly, every piece of timber has a different coefficient of strength. The strength is dependent on its usage and seasoning. What sets it apart from other building materials is its beauty, warmth and value besides cutting down on carbon emissions when plantation wood is opted for. Wood, when used in the interiors as panelling, or as rafters in the ceiling, or heavily in windows, on floors, can add a warmth and old world charm to the décor depending on the manner of depiction. Furniture made of wood, even sans intricate carving, can lend a rich tone. When represented in exotic forms, it appears stately and opulent, totally transforming the décor. Given the extensive use of wood historically in structures and interiors, most of the thematic representations of décor calls for extensive use of timber. While hardwood tends to last for centuries with little maintenance when seasoned right and kept indoors, wood can also be highly manipulated. It can be bent, sanded, cut, joined, and strengthened with pins. Interestingly no two pieces of wood are alike, which adds to its versatility. Natural seasoning Says Architect Satish Naik, Satish Naik & Associates, “Seasoning of wood can be done artificially as well as naturally though natural seasoning is lengthier, requiring soaking of logs in water and later drying in sunlight. A well-seasoned wood does not warp, bend or slit.” The manner of usage also determines its strength. For instance, teak yields maximum strength when used vertically while bamboo is totally flexible, allowing any manner of use. Says Architect Dinesh Verma, ACE Group Architects, “Bamboo can be assembled faster than other types of timber and withstands better harsher weather conditions.” Teak lends itself to decoration given its natural properties while bamboo serves as an excellent support for roofs where it can serve as structural element for the entire stretch of walls as well as ceiling. Stunning dwellings can be created using only bamboo. In rural areas, entire houses are made of bamboo. Bamboo is also excellent for creating exotic varieties of furniture and artefacts. “Bamboo roots come in exquisite shapes that lend themselves to creating mindboggling varieties of art pieces and furniture,” adds Naik. Some of the early uses of timber veered around mahogany, ebony, rose, teak, camphor and walnut. These varieties were crafted to reflect superb craftsmanship. Rosewood, teak and walnut are still sparingly used though the opulent mahogany and the queen of timber, ebony, have gone completely out of circulation, with ebony now listed under the preserved category. The black-coloured ebony is also credited with healing properties, manifesting as hand railings in mansions. Interestingly, only a small portion of ebony’s trunk forms the core of the timber with the rest assuming a lighter shade. Rare Paduk Paduk is another interesting variety of timber found in the forests of Andaman and is unique as it is grown only in this region. “The rare Paduk, referred as the chameleon of timber, has an interesting characteristic of losing its colour completely when exposed to sunlight and regaining it once brought back under shade,” says Naik. Many new varieties of timber have now come to use, each with their own unique individual characteristics, notable ones being sal wood, beach wood, steam wood, American walnut, and rubber wood. Cane too has come to occupy a significant space in timber varieties. Given its lightness, cane is becoming more popular especially with exotic varieties of furniture being crafted using it. Interestingly, even discarded wooden railway sleepers form excellent material for outdoor use. Adds Verma, “These can be used as garden seating elements, to pave the pathways in the garden, even for cladding the façade to give a woody cottage look to the residence.” One of Verma’s residence projects displays such exterior cladding where the hard wooden planks have been bolted in to facilitate easy removal for maintenance. Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Investment, investments, News, Property, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Timber Rules