Tag Archives: government

Can China Achieve Success With Carbon Trading Scheme?

By Puneet Pal Singh Business Reporter, BBC News China’s rapid industrialization has contributed to the rising pollution levels in the country Over the past few years China has earned itself quite a few crowns in the “world’s-biggest” category. It has become the world’s biggest internet market, largest car market, biggest exporter… the list goes on and on. While Beijing takes a lot of pride in some of these achievements, there is one title that it wants to let go of sooner rather than later, that of being the world’s biggest polluter. And in an attempt to do so, China has launched a pilot project of its first ever carbon trading scheme in Shenzhen. “This is definitely a big game-changer for China,” says Winnie Tang, a director with Kind Resources, an investment and deal advisory firm which focuses on carbon emission reduction. “It is a clear indication that they are serious about reducing emissions and bringing down pollution levels.” ‘Market-based policy’ Under carbon trading, firms are given credits – each equal to one tonne of carbon emissions. There is a cap on the credits issued to ensure that firms keep their emissions under control. “It is still a very new concept to the Chinese firms. They have little experience in recording their emissions and trading carbon credits” The companies are required to measure and report their carbon emissions and to hand in one allowance for each tonne of carbon they release. If companies emit less carbon than their allowance, they can trade their credits. On the other hand, if their emission levels exceed the limit, they have to buy fresh credits – thus putting a price on pollution. “It is a market-based policy. If someone emits more – they have to pay for it,” says Princeton Peng, chief executive of Climate Bridge, a firm specialising in carbon trading and offset project development. Mr Peng says this is likely to force companies to implement policies aimed at bringing down their emission levels and as a result help reduce overall pollution. China’s carbon trading scheme pilot projects Location Companies trading emissions Emissions covered SOURCE:CARBON MARKET WATCH Beijing 420 – 600 50% Shanghai 197 50% Tianjin 120 60% Chongqing NA NA Shenzhen 635 40% Guangdong 830 42% – 50% Hubei NA 35%    European lesson? However, there are also concerns in China about what will happen to the price of credits when companies start to trade them. Some say that the price of these credits will rise as China looks to cut pollution levels, which may spark speculative trades. An excessive movement in the pricing of credits, on either side, could be detrimental to the overall objective of the scheme. “If the price goes too high, it will severely impact the operations of the companies,” says Mr Peng of Climate Bridge. Carbon emissions in China – key milestones 2006: Preliminary plan for nationwide emission trading scheme outlined 2008: Environment and energy exchanges established in Beijing, Shanghai and Tianjin 2010: 12th five-year plan lists carbon markets as key measure for reducing carbon and energy intensities 2011: Seven carbon trading pilots announced 2013: Shenzhen pilot starts Source: Climate Bridge “On the other hand, if the market price is too low – there is no incentive for people to reduce emission and invest in clean energy solutions.” These concerns stem in part from the developments in the European Union’s carbon trading market – currently the world’s biggest. The European Union (EU) market has seen the price of credits falling to $4 per tonne in recent weeks, from $40 per tonne a few years ago. Analysts blame the sharp decline on two key issues. They say that the rise in prices after the launch of the scheme in 2008 was triggered in part by traders who speculated that the carbon prices would keep rising. At the same time, they argue that authorities issued excessive amounts of credits which narrowed the demand-and-supply gap. That coupled with an overall slowdown in the EU economy resulted in the price of the credits falling and raised concerns about the future of the scheme. However, analysts say that Beijing has had the opportunity to learn from the developments in the EU and has fine-tuned its scheme. “No one really knows what is going to happen with the China market, but they have done their research on what the EU got wrong and are less likely to make those mistakes,” says Ms Tang. ‘Learning process’ The pilot in Shenzen is the first of seven such projects that will be launched in China over the next few months. Beijing plans to eventually launch a nationwide carbon trading scheme by 2015-16. Analysts say that by piloting the scheme across different areas, China is looking to ensure that it can tackle any teething issues and iron them out before the country-wide launch. “This will be a learning process both for the government and companies,” says Yue-tan David Tang, secretary of the board of Tianjin Climate Exchange. “The companies will have to learn how to take part in the emissions market. “The government will have the time and the opportunity to improve upon emission data infrastructure – which includes the quality of data collected and how it is collected,” he explains. Mr Tang adds that there is political will in China to get the scheme rolling and the success of the pilot programmes will only strengthen that commitment. When launched nationwide, the scheme is likely see China emerge as the world’s biggest carbon trading market. And if that helps to bring down pollution levels substantially, it will be one crown that Beijing will wear with pride. Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Investment, investments, News, Property, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Can China Achieve Success With Carbon Trading Scheme?

Future Points To Carbon Trading

China Daily, June 14, 2013 Smoke billows from a factory in Dezhou, Shandong province. To reach mandatory efficiency goals, the government had to take some extreme steps, including power cuts and limits on electricity supply in 2010. [China Daily] Chinese companies that have long faced relatively low environmental costs will have to figure out efficient ways to cut carbon dioxide emissions as a market mechanism is right around the corner. The country’s first pilot carbon-trading program for cutting greenhouse gas emissions will make its formal debut on Tuesday in Shenzhen, the southern city in Guangdong province that has long been a leader in China’s reforms. The Shenzhen pilot program is expected to hasten the launch of pilots in other regions. The central government has designated four other cities, including Beijing and Shanghai, and two provinces to roll out pilot carbon-trading programs by 2014. In Shenzhen, about 635 companies accounted for about 38 percent of the city’s total emissions, and they will be included in the experimental program. Using a 2012 baseline of carbon dioxide emissions of roughly 31.73 million tons, Shenzhen will issue 100 million tons of free emissions allowances to companies complying with the program between 2013 and 2015. Rather than copy cap-and-trade programs in Europe or California, the Shenzhen pilot sets limits on carbon intensity (carbon dioxide emissions per unit of GDP) for emitters. The 635 companies must achieve an average annual carbon intensity reduction of 6.68 percent by 2015. However, regions will explore various approaches in establishing their own experimental programs. Cities such as Beijing might adopt absolute emission caps, said industrial experts. Carbon intensity “Adopting a carbon intensity index is in line with China’s commitment of reducing carbon intensity,” said Yang Fuqiang, senior adviser on energy, environment and climate change for the Natural Resources Defense Council in Beijing. China has set a target of reducing carbon intensity by 40 to 45 percent by 2020, compared with the 2005 levels. Carbon intensity reduction leaves room for growth by allowing a limited increase of carbon emissions, said Yang. “All approaches could be used, but the final target is to have a nationwide market, and some kind of top-level programs should be put in place,” said Yang. Most international carbon markets adopt absolute caps, but it still remains uncertain when China will reach an absolute peak in emissions. Before the two-week climate change talks in Bonn in early June, the peak issue was already in the limelight. Some media reports said China’s greenhouse gas emissions might peak before 2025 and the country might introduce a cap in 2016. Reports about an early cap were dismissed by Su Wei, China’s chief climate negotiator in Bonn, while he reaffirmed China’s commitment to a carbon-intensity target by 2020. The peak issue is part of the agenda for China in its sustainable development, but when it will happen requires more in-depth analysis, said Zhou Dadi, vice-chairman of the National Energy Advisory Committee. Various studies have yielded wide variations for China’s carbon emissions peak, ranging from 2025 to 2040. “The year of 2025, or the period between 2025 and 2030, each has a high probability, but a precondition is China’s energy demand for industrialization, which could peak by 2020, and the country could then enter a post-industrial era,” said Yang. Another key factor is the speed of China’s urbanization. The quicker the process is, the earlier the country’s emissions peak will come, Yang said. Many Shenzhen businesses are willing to experiment with the new mechanism since it could also generate new business opportunities, though some power plants may be reluctant to adopt the new system, said experts who were involved in the design of the program. The cost of environmental degradation has been largely ignored during China’s impressive economic development in recent decades, putting mounting pressure on the government. Environmental costs To reach China’s mandatory efficiency goals, the government had to take some extreme steps, including power cuts and limits on electricity supply in 2010. “A market-based mechanism will surely work better than administrative measures. Companies should internalize environmental costs that were previously taken by the government,” said Tang Renhu, general manager of Beijing-based Sino-Carbon Innovation and Investment Co. To avoid a low price in carbon auctions, regulators in some markets may set a floor price. Prices that are too low reduce companies’ incentive to invest in technology to cut down emissions. But according to experts, the Shenzhen pilot program has yet to set either a floor or a ceiling on carbon prices for auction. For energy-conservation projects, the central government offers a subsidy of 240 yuan ($39) for each ton of coal equivalent saved, while provincial-level governments offer about 60 yuan. Based on that, the reference carbon price is about 100 yuan per ton, said Tang. This number “could be a reference to the market, but the price needs to be decided by the market,” he said. California established its carbon market last November with quarterly auctions of carbon allowances, making it the second-largest carbon market in the world after the EU’s Emission Trading Scheme or ETS. California set a $10 price floor for its first allowance auction in November. The carbon allowances were actually sold at $10.09 a ton. In its second auction in February, the price rose to $13.62 a ton, and the price then hit a record of $14 in the third auction in May. Gary Gero, president of the California-based Climate Action Reserve, said the most affected companies are electric utilities, petroleum refineries and large manufacturing facilities. Most companies will assess the costs of implementing on-site emission reductions relative to the cost of an allowance or offset and then pursue the most cost-effective reduction opportunities. “This is the very point of a cap-and-trade program; it provides the largest amount of emission reductions at the least possible cost, thereby reducing the economic impact on businesses and consumers,” said Gero. This program will result in the shifting of energy production to cleaner fuels and technologies as the program progresses and after the least expensive reductions have been identified and implemented, he added. The problems of the EU’s ETS, the largest player in the global carbon market, are mostly due to two related issues: the excessive allocation of permits and carbon price volatility. Justin Dargin, energy and carbon markets expert at the University of Oxford, said China should not be overly concerned about the success or failure of carbon markets outside its jurisdiction. The reason that China is concerned about the development of carbon markets has mostly to do with transitioning its economy away from an energy-intensive model. The introduction of energy-efficient industrial equipment would also lower China’s aggregate energy consumption. That would help China meet its energy security goals for the medium and longer term. These goals are relatively independent of developments outside of China, said Dargin. Yet, China can learn from other jurisdictions and therefore should pay close attention to the best practices and “lessons learned” elsewhere. Dargin suggested setting a carbon price floor that is high enough to create incentives for industry to invest in clean technology, while at the same time not being too high to hinder industrial competitiveness. The price band should also attempt to minimize volatility as much as possible. Xie Zhenhua, China’s top climate change official, said in April that China will draw lessons from the EU’s ETS, the world’s biggest emissions trading system, which has had a lingering oversupply of carbon allowances and low prices. Challenges ahead Setting standards and building the capacity of China’s carbon market takes time, but the biggest hurdle might be China’s sluggish energy pricing system reform. Whether electricity rates are determined by the market will be a core concern of building a carbon market, said Dargin. “Without a market-determined price, the imposition of a carbon price on power producers would have little impact as power producers are not allowed to pass on costs to end-users and resist absorbing these costs themselves,” he said. Carbon is a product that is closely linked to energy, but China’s energy prices are still mainly controlled by the government. But this year the government has showed signs of accelerating its energy price reforms. The National Development and Reform Commission in March launched a more market-oriented fuel pricing system to better reflect costs. Economists said relatively low inflation levels have provided favorable conditions for energy pricing reform. The healthy development of the carbon market will eventually rely on reform of the energy pricing system, said Tang. “It’s difficult to (do things that) affect vested interests among energy groups, so starting the carbon market could be a force to help accelerate reform in the energy sector, but that also brings major challenges for China’s carbon market,” said Tang. Also, integration among different markets will be a challenge, he said. Local pilot projects may have some limitations such as small trading pools for suppliers and buyers, so the central government should allow them to extend trading with other regions, said experts. Also, potential fraud must be monitored by regulators to ensure that the market has adequate oversight and transparency. As carbon exchanges open in various cities, information security must be monitored and made robust, said Dargin. For instance, regulators shut down the EU’s ETS after hackers stole more than 3 million carbon credits from government and private company accounts. Furthermore, penalties for non-compliance must be clear. What are the penalties if emitters exceed their emissions caps and do not pay the levied fines? This needs to be clearly stated, said Dargin. Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Investment, investments, News, Property, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Future Points To Carbon Trading

Emerging Markets Mid-Year Pulse Check

Some markets do appear to have a weak pulse right now, but any number of catalysts could act as a jump start. Global economic growth hasn’t been terribly inspiring so far in the first half of the year, but many investors have nevertheless been inspired to pour more assets into the equity markets, some of which have surged to record highs. As we hit the mid-year point, now seems like a good time to take a pulse check of emerging markets and assess our prognosis. About the Author At Franklin Templeton, we never lose sight of why we’re here: to provide investors with exceptional asset management. That’s why our independent, specialized management teams are at the heart of our business. These dedicated portfolio groups allow us to offer focused expertise across a broad range of strategies and asset classes. Several emerging and frontier markets—including the Philippines, Indonesia, Thailand and Vietnam in Southeast Asia—have seen strong returns in recent months. And there are several other notable emerging market performers where positive local macroeconomic developments have attracted strong investment flows. Given that yields on some assets seen as “safe” are close to record lows, the attraction to potentially higher-yielding, but riskier assets such as emerging-market equities has continued to grow. Of course, we’ve seen some disappointments too. Some larger emerging markets like South Africa, South Korea, Russia, China and Brazil have lost ground year-to-date through April. Reduced GDP growth forecasts certainly didn’t help and commodity-heavy markets took a double hit as reduced growth projections depressed commodity prices at the same time indications of rising production costs pressured individual mining and energy companies. In addition, sentiment in South Korea suffered amid threats from North Korea and fears Japan’s moves to depress the yen’s value would hurt South Korean exporters. In China, the authorities responded to rising property prices with measures to tighten monetary policy and restrict property purchases. In addition, some political and market developments in Brazil, India and Russia suggested that policy development was moving in a less shareholder-friendly direction.  For example, in Brazil, the government has initiated major tax claims against some large companies. In my team’s opinion, many of these issues that held back the performance of major emerging markets in recent months are likely to have little long-term impact. Tensions on the Korean peninsula tend to fluctuate over time, and we believe an escalation of the current situation into actual conflict is highly unlikely. We also think yen weakness is unlikely to be a permanent drag on South Korean export performance. And, China’s moves to cool property markets should be seen in the context of strong ongoing growth and moves to rebalance the economy toward more sustainable growth models. Some policy moves that came with short-term costs could ultimately bring long-term benefits, such as anti-corruption measures that led to reduced demand for luxury items during the Chinese New Year. In Russia, shareholder rights issues are balanced by what we see as exceptionally cheap equity valuations. Meanwhile, the overall direction of policy in both India and Brazil remains market-oriented. Most importantly, we believe recent commodity weakness does not represent a long-term trend. The Case for Emerging Markets’ Growth Despite a recent moderation in short-term global GDP growth forecasts, we still anticipate a likely reacceleration of growth in 2013 and in subsequent years, with 2012 expected to mark a low point. Moreover, we expect growth generally in emerging markets in 2013 and beyond longer term to be much stronger than in developed markets and believe such strong growth could not only drive rising demand for commodities, but also feed into corporate profitability and valuations over time. Industrialization and urbanization in emerging markets are likely to further increase commodity demand, which could push prices ahead over the long term. In many emerging economies, commodities, exports and infrastructure development could continue to be leading growth drivers, but we believe going forward, overall growth is likely to arise increasingly from domestic sources. Expanding consumer wealth is creating an increasingly large and discriminating body of middle class consumers across emerging markets, and their demand is in turn creating increasingly significant domestic economic activity. Furthermore, emerging markets have far lower levels of consumer indebtedness than is common in developed markets, giving their consumers commensurately greater capacity to ramp up demand. In addition, demographic factors are more favorable in many emerging markets than in most developed markets. With a relatively high proportion of the population in emerging markets moving into the workforce and a relatively low proportion of dependents, demographics are acting to reinforce consumer demand. Even in markets like China, where demographics are less clearly favorable, productivity gains from moves out of agriculture and into manufacturing and service industries have still provided a positive influence on growth and domestic demand. Frontier Markets – Emerging Markets of the Future These so-called “emerging markets of the future” have enjoyed strong growth from low base effects, abundant natural and human resources, the availability of easy gains from market reforms and injections of technology into relatively low-wage economies. Compared with more mature emerging markets, frontier markets are relatively under-researched, and we believe that this lack of familiarity could lead to undervaluation and pricing anomalies that we could seek to exploit through our extensive research resources. We are finding many opportunities in frontier markets globally, but with an especially dense pack of opportunities, we think Africa in general represents an investment destination all its own and one we are eyeing with particular interest. We remain aware of risks to all markets, including emerging markets, arising from the fragility of global growth, indebtedness, and a number of geopolitical risks, notably in Korea, the South China Sea and the Middle East. However, while we take account of macroeconomic considerations as part of our investment process, our central aim is to build portfolios from those stocks our research leads us to believe are most underpriced relative to their long-term potential. My prognosis: Some markets do appear to have a weak pulse right now, but any number of catalysts could act as a jump start. Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Investment, investments, News, Property, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Emerging Markets Mid-Year Pulse Check