Tag Archives: europe

Expert View: What Next For The EU ETS?

17 Apr 2013, 17:00 Sarah Deblock and Bryony Worthington The European Parliament yesterday rejected backloading, a plan to withhold emissions permits from the European Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) to combat oversupply in the market. So can the ETS recover? Two experts give their views. Without backloading, ETS reform may be undermined Sarah Deblock, policy director for European affairs for the International Emissions Trading Association Backloading is not new. First known as the set-aside proposal, the European Parliament originally proposed it as a solution to address oversupply in the market around two years ago. So why has the parliament now rejected backloading? In recent months, MEPs’ positions across the political spectrum have fractured. Yesterday, nearly 70 per cent of MEPs in the influential right-of-centre EPP group, 86 per cent of the European Conservatives and Reformists, and 40 per cent of the liberal ALDE group rejected the proposal. Just 19 votes out of a total of 754 swung the decision. The result has hurt political confidence in the emissions trading scheme. However, while the vote failed to provide a clear political commitment to the proposal for addressing the current oversupply in the EU ETS, it has also led to public assurances of those MEPs who believe in emissions trading and the need for structural reform, but who do not see backloading as being a necessary part of this process. Many of those MEPs opposed to backloading viewed it as a short term measure only, and did not support that type of market intervention. Therefore, as additional information emerges, most MEPs would argue that their opposition to the backloading proposal is not to be interpreted as opposition to the EU ETS. Moreover a majority of the anti-backloading camp is publicly supportive of reform. But although structural reform is likely to happen with or without backloading, it will be much harder to restructure the ETS if nothing is introduced to make the market more efficient. Backloading is also a way to buy time to avoid the carbon price collapsing further. Without it, the price of permits is likely to start rising and falling depending on speculation over political developments rather than market signals. And if MEPs begin new discussions on long-term structural reform in a context in which the ETS is working inefficiently, the discussions could get sidetracked from redesigning the scheme long-term in favour of a short-term fix. More time is needed for a meaningful reform so that the carbon market can automatically adjust when the economy takes a turn for better or worse. What’s worse, the political situation in Europe is likely to delay ETS reform. With the European elections taking place in May 2014, the new commission is not expected to be formally in place before early 2015. Once a new legislative proposal for reform materialises, it’s likely to take another year or two to get through the European Parliament and European Council. This delay means that without backloading, the ETS is likely to run inefficiently until at least 2016. This will increase the temptation for governments to implement alternative instruments like carbon taxes, even though most politicians would agree that an EU-wide policy instrument such as the EU ETS is more desirable than a patchwork of 27 different national policies. The time has now come to make a strong political commitment to the existing scheme, to acknowledge its difficulties, and to discuss the options on the table for reform. The outcome will also have an effect on the emissions trading schemes that are developing worldwide. Recent examples include Australia, California and the north-Eastern US states, which are starting to look to link to other carbon markets. Progress is also noticeable in the developing world in China, South Korea, Kazakhstan, and Chile. The EU ETS is the biggest emissions trading scheme in the world, and as it is facing challenges, all eyes are on Europe to see how it will address these difficulties. Member states must clarify their position to move the debate forward. The ETS will limp along, but Europe will pay for the delay to reform Bryony Worthington , director and founder of cap and trade campaign organisation Sandbag With the European Parliament’s vote against backloading, the future of the ETS in Europe the short term looks pretty bleak. The carbon price – already at rock bottom – has fallen by close to half. The immediate implications of this are that carbon auctions may struggle to go ahead if bids fail to meet reserve prices. EU member states that have been banking on incomes from carbon auctions to fund public services or supporting green policies will find they have a hole in their finances. This could prompt countries to follow the UK’s lead and introduce carbon taxes to compensate. If policies across Europe start to splinter, it will lead to distortions in trade – and that’s bad for business. The low prices also mean Europe’s most efficient businesses are no longer rewarded for doing the right thing, and those that rely on revenue from selling surplus permits will lose a potential lifeline. In the medium term, it is possible that a more ambitious proposal than the current ETS could emerge from one of the European institutions. A number of MEPs abstained, while several who rejected backloading have said they support fixing the ETS – just not through this measure. Both may support a different approach if one can be agreed. If nothing emerges ahead of the next parliamentary elections in May next year, it will be two years or more before anything can be done at an EU level. In the long term, the ETS will simply carry on regardless – there is nothing in the legislation that can cause it to cease. Prices will inevitably rise in around 10 years as industrial permit surpluses dry up, free allocations disappear and carbon offsetting provisions run out. Sadly for the EU, to sit around doing very little for the rest of the decade would lead to loss of investment. It would also send a very bad signal to other governments.   For this reason, it seems likely the European Commission will now shift its focus to deciding climate targets for 2030. If targets come in at the same time as changes to the ETS, they could speed up a rise in the carbon price. Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Investment, investments, News, Property, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Expert View: What Next For The EU ETS?

Europe’s Climate Chief Vows To Fight On To Save Emissions Trading Scheme

Connie Hedegaard’s attempts to introduce longer-term reforms will face fierce opposition from a powerful business lobby Fiona Harvey in Brussels guardian.co.uk , Wednesday 17 April 2013 17.43 BS Connie Hedegaard, EU commissioner for climate action, at a press conference on a 2030 framework for EU climate change and energy policies. Photograph: Etienne Ansotte/Shimera/EU Press office Europe ‘s climate chief vowed on Wednesday to fight on to save the EU’s flagship environmental policy, the emissions trading system (ETS), after a serious blow on Tuesday when MEPs rejected reforms aimed at repairing the ailing system . MEPs voted 334 against to 315 in favour of “backloading” the market – a proposal aimed to reverse the plummeting price of carbon that has resulted from a surplus of permits in the ETS market – leading the price of carbon to fall by almost half to under €3 on Tuesday. Connie Hedegaard, EU commissioner for climate action, said: “We are preparing structural [longer-term reforms]. We will have new meetings for stakeholders, in parallel with an impact assessment. We are preparing an initiative.” The proposals include measures to restrict rights to carbon permits under the system, and to allow for reviews of the number of permits companies receive for free. Phil Hogan, the Irish environment minister who holds responsibility for the portfolio under the Irish presidency, said: “We are not prepared to allow this issue to die. We have a working party, and we will see what we have to do to put [this issue] up to people in a democratic process.” These attempts will face fierce opposition, however, from a powerful business lobby that has opposed the penalties on carbon dioxide emissions that Europe has sought to impose, in order to tackle climate change . The EU ETS, which began in 2005 and covers the majority of the EU’s energy-intensive industries, is one of only two major carbon dioxide trading systems in the world, intended to cut emissions by putting a price on carbon. The vote by the European parliament to throw out reform proposals was seen by analysts and traders as a potentially fatal blow. Much more is at stake than the EU’s own emissions. A breakdown of the scheme, which is the cornerstone of the European commission ‘s efforts to tackle global warming, would severely damage Europe’s reputation as a global leader on climate issues and diminish the bloc’s clout in ongoing international climate change negotiations aimed at replacing the 1997 Kyoto protocol . Mechanisms such as emissions trading are viewed as essential to force countries and businesses to cut their greenhouse gases, at a time when global emissions are still rising strongly despite ever more stark warnings from scientists. Hedegaard said the commission had already put in train a variety of proposals that would require far-reaching structural reform to the trading system. Under the ETS, energy intensive industries are allocated or required to purchase carbon permits to cover the emissions they produce. The resulting penalty on carbon emissions is supposed to act as an incentive for companies to become more efficient and invest in cleaner technologies, such as renewable energy. But the system has been troubled since soon after its inception, when it was found that member states had allocated far too many free carbon permits to their industries, resulting in a crash in the carbon price. Permit prices recovered when the rules were tightened, but that was in good economic times – when recession struck from 2008-09, many companies were producing far less while still receiving mountains of free permits. That resulted in a massive surplus of permits in a market that relies on scarcity for its very existence – the resulting price of carbon has been so low, at a few euros per tonne, that it provides no incentive for businesses to change their behaviour. The reforms that were rejected on Tuesday would have shored up the price of carbon, by postponing planned auctions of 900m new permits. But some business groupings lobbied hard against the proposals, which they said would impose costs on companies that overseas competitors do not face, and the vote was narrowly lost – in part because a number of the UK’s Tory MEPs rebelled against David Cameron’s party line. For carbon traders and campaigners, the MEPs’ rejection of “backloading” – the postponement, not cancellation, of permit auctions – was a disaster. Stig Schjølset, head of EU carbon analysis at Thomson Reuters Point Carbon, said the vote would “make EU ETS irrelevant as an emissions reduction tool for many years to come” and that it was “very unlikely that any political intervention in the scheme will be agreed during the third phase from 2013 to 2020”. As a result, he predicted the price of carbon would not rise much above its current €3s and could fall again before 2020. BusinessEurope, a business group that spearheaded the lobbying of MEPs to reject the shorting up of the carbon market, said its members had been “unanimous” in opposing backloading. However, other business groupings have disagreed, including the CBI which supports shoring up the EU’s carbon price. Milton Catelin, chief executive of the World Coal Association, called the European parliament vote “a triumph of common sense and balanced policy”. Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Investment, investments, News, Property, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Europe’s Climate Chief Vows To Fight On To Save Emissions Trading Scheme

Global Cooling On Carbon

Thursday, 18 April 2013 If you think gold’s recent swan dive was unnerving, spare a thought for those who bought carbon credits – that’s where the climate change has really happened. Gold has recouped some of its losses over the past two trading sessions, but it remains 26.9% below the all-time closing high of US$1,898.25 an ounce reached on 5 September 2011. It’s bad, it’s bad, you know it. Just ask John Paulson who reportedly lost US$1.5 billion of his personal wealth betting on the shiny metal (though it’s still a paper loss until he sells his holdings). Just ask the central banks, which according to Bloomberg, has lost US$560 billion this year. I betcha Paulson & Co. and the central banks would not be feeling all that bad — nay they would be laughing — that they didn’t buy into the emissions trading scheme business as well. For the price of carbon has not only fallen it has collapsed. It closed at US$3.61 last night, down 17% from the previous day for a total dive of…wait for it…92.9% from the US$50.66 high posted on 11 July 2008. Yeouch! As with many of the troubles that still plague the global economy, this too is made in Europe. Carbon prices fell after the European Parliament rejected the European Commission’s plan to backload – that is, take 900 million tonnes of carbon credits off market and return them when the region’s economy is stronger (in three years? five years? 10 years?). The rejection was for all the good of Europe. It’ll reduce costs for European businesses, especially the energy intensive ones, and it’ll lower European consumers’ living expenses, mainly energy bills. They need that with many national governments on an austerity crusade – reducing fiscal spending here and raising taxes there. Whatever works to keep the Eurozone economy working again. And once more, like any made in Europe predicament, it spells contagion…into Australia in particular. You can almost taste Ernest Miller Hemingway’s immortal words, “don’t ask for whom the bells toll, it tolls for thee”. Did I say you, I mean Julia and Wayne. For just as we Australians all, seemed to have warmed to Julia’s flip on the carbon tax, the international price has collapsed. Australian energy guzzlers are currently paying a fixed price of A$23 per tonne and by 2014/15 this will increase to A$25.40 — all the while when the international price is around US$3.60 (A$3.74). It comes as no surprise therefore that you hear Australian businesses – led by the Business Council of Australia and the Australian Industry Group – clamouring, “I’ll have what she’s having”. That’s tough for Wayne Swan who’ll be presenting the Budget to us Australians all in less than a month’s time. The last Budget predicts a carbon price of A$29 a tonne by 2015/16. This would put an extra A$6.7 billion in the government’s coffers. Financial markets see the carbon price at A$3.46 a tonne by July 2015. What happens to Wayne’s forecast revenue then? But this is still two years away. Unless a miracle happens, Labor would not be in government by then and it’ll be up to Tony to blame why the Budget remains in deficit on Labor. Continue reading →

Posted on by tsiadmin | Posted in Investment, investments, News, Property, Taylor Scott International, TSI, Uk | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Global Cooling On Carbon