Tag Archives: europe
Crikey Clarifier: Why Is The EU Carbon Scheme Hitting Our Budget?
Monday, 20 May 2013 Erwin Jackson Crikey Clarifier Last week’s federal budget showed the impact that Europe’s emissions trading scheme is having on Australia’s carbon scheme. The EU carbon price is currently a low 3.55 euros (A$4.67) per tonne of CO2. From 2015, when Australia’s carbon scheme is due to morph into an ETS and will be linked with the EU carbon market, our carbon price is now forecast to be much lower than expected. In the short term, this means less revenue from Australia’s carbon price — hence some budget cuts to climate programs last week. So why is the European carbon price so low — and what’s going to happen next? Firstly, don’t let this issue distract the debate from the fundamentals. The threat of repeal of the carbon price under a Coalition government creates far greater short-term uncertainty around Australia’s carbon price than the low EU carbon price does. For an investor, decisions around the future of EU carbon markets pale against the prospect of doing business in a country that would be the first to dismantle a carbon market. Secondly, the basic rationale for building the link between the two schemes (Australia’s and the EU’s) remains strong. In the longer term, linked markets will be central to boosting the more ambitious global action needed to cut emissions. Remember all the calls for Australia to wait till there is a global market for carbon? It’s not going to pop into place like Dr Who from the Tardis. It is going to come from markets growing and linking. Like Australia’s and EUs, like California’s and Quebec’s, and like China’s seven pilot schemes (China’s national scheme is due to start after 2015). Thirdly, recent budget changes in clean energy and other programs show that an over-reliance on the purse strings of governments does not provide policy stability. The government is better placed to define clear rules for the private sector to follow to reduce emissions. These are the principal policies that can help the government (of whichever party) meet the full range of their bipartisan target to cut emissions by 5 to 25% by 2020 (on 2000 levels). Why is the European carbon price low, and is it a problem? The main reason for the low EU price is that the limit Europe has placed on emissions is not ambitious enough. Like Australia, the EU plans to use the cap it places on emissions from its domestic industries as the principal mechanism to achieve its pollution targets. The economic downturn and the emission reductions from its ambitious renewable energy and energy efficiency policies mean the EU is likely to over-achieve its current 2020 target (i.e. it will pollute less than the cap). The EU system is acting like the market should — emissions are down, demand for emission credits is soft, so the price is low. This problem has been exacerbated by the EU being too generous in giving away free emission credits to some industries, and the lack of flexibility to adjust to changed circumstances. This is not a problem for the EU in meeting its emission targets at lowest cost. But it is a problem if you are an investor seeking to bankroll a major investment in clean energy (this is why the UK has implemented a minimum carbon price in its domestic electricity industry of around A$25/tonne). We are already seeing the EU starting to be challenged by Asia, particularly China, as the world’s clean energy superpower. Without stronger long, loud and legal price signals this is likely to continue. Why has the situation not been fixed so far? Recent attempts to bolster confidence in the EU carbon market have narrowly been put off by countries such as Poland, which want to protect their coal interests, or those that say “let the market sort itself out”. Upcoming German elections have not helped either. Chancellor Angela Merkel has been more timid than normal in sending a strong signal that the EU needs to be a leader in climate change. Does it seem that the EU will solve the problem? Even without short-term interventions, eventually, yes. The fundamentals of the European carbon market indicate prices will rise later this decade as market participants start to factor in the EU’s post-2020 emission caps (the EU has agreed to reduce its domestic emissions by 80-95% below 1990 levels by 2050). Current forecasts by market analysts suggest that EU carbon prices will average around A$10/tonne (a range of $3-$17) over the period to 2020, and up to $39/tonne in 2020. The European Commission is also re-engaging parliamentarians. In June it will revisit proposals to bolster short-term prices. The commission has also begun the process that seeks to strengthen the EU’s 2030 emission targets, which would result in even higher prices emerging later this decade. How would a low European carbon price affect Australia (especially from 2015)? A lower EU carbon a price means that meeting Australia’s emission targets can occur more cheaply. Australia should commit to a fairer contribution to global climate action and toughen its current minimum target to cut emissions by 5% by 2020 — the minimum should be around a 15% cut. Low short-term prices strengthen the case for policies such as the Renewable Energy Target to help grow a lower carbon Australian economy, until global prices better reflect the benefits of reducing emissions in the medium to long term. Continue reading
Taking Stock of Climate Change Efforts: As European Carbon Market Falters, CA Expands Cap and Trade to Canada
May 20, 2013 Unlike many environmental problems, which can be addressed at a local or regional scale, climate change is inherently global in nature: greenhouse gas (“GHG”) emissions from any source join with historic and contemporary GHG emissions from other sources globally to contribute to the total store of GHGs in the atmosphere. The global nature of the issue is a key reason why, from the onset of climate change efforts, policymakers and environmentalists have attempted to address GHG emissions at an international scale. Failure of Kyoto Protocol Leaves Void in International Climate Change Efforts The primary effort to address climate change at an international scale is the Kyoto Protocol, adopted in 1997 in connection with the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Unfortunately, through the first “commitment period” (which ended in 2012), the Kyoto Protocol has not achieved expectations, as the two largest GHG emitting countries—China and the United States—never signed the Protocol. The sense that the Kyoto Protocol will ultimately fail as a climate program was compounded by the inability of negotiators at the 2009 Copenhagen Summit to agree on a framework for climate change mitigation for the period following the end of the first commitment period in 2012. Since Copenhagen, climate policymakers have looked for a regional model to lead the way to a new international climate framework. European Trading System in Disarray With the Kyoto Protocol faltering, hopes have been pinned on the European Union’s climate change program—the Emissions Trading Scheme (“ETS”). These hopes are rapidly fading. In the past few months, the ETS has experience significant growing pains, with the price of carbon allowances having dropped from about € 25 per ton in 2008 to below € 3 per ton in April. Although reductions in GHG emissions in the EU are still on pace to meet the target of the Europe 2020 Strategy (20% lower than 1990 emissions), most analysts believe that carbon prices at this level are too low to spur investment. The severe drop in carbon allowance prices has led many, including The Economist , to question whether the ETS has any future. California Expanding its Cap and Trade Program to Canadian Province of Quebec In the midst of Europe’s difficulties, California has moved forward to link its cap and trade system with that of the Canadian Province of Quebec. On April 19, 2013, the California Air Resources Board (“CARB”) approved a plan to formally link with Quebec beginning on January 1, 2014. Linkage will create a relatively seamless cap and trade market, with compliance instruments—carbon allowances and offset credits—being interchangeable in the two systems. California and Quebec will also hold joint auctions of carbon allowances. The linkage of the California and Quebec cap and trade systems is a modest first step towards a robust North American cap and trade system. Although Quebec is Canada’s largest province by size and has a population of about eight million people (second only to Ontario among provinces), its economy is not nearly as large as that of California: Quebec has a GDP of about $300 billion compared to California’s GDP of about $1.9 trillion. About 80 entities (referred to as “establishments” in Quebec’s program) are subject to Quebec’s cap and trade regulations. In comparison, California’s cap and trade program covers about 350 entities representing 600 facilities. Also, Quebec’s allowable GHG emissions are substantially lower than those of California: Quebec’s cap starts at about 23.2 million tons of GHG emissions (CO 2 e) in 2013 and ends at about 54.7 million tons in 2020, while California’s cap starts at about 162 million tons of GHG emissions (CO 2 e) in 2013 and ends at about 334 million tons in 2020. (Note that the increase reflects the addition of transportation fuels and natural gas in 2015; over time, the cap will go down — become more stringent —for all covered sectors.) Testing the New Model CARB recognizes that a key aspect of linkage with Quebec is that it may establish a new template for climate change efforts globally. As stated by CARB in its response to comments: “[T]he experience gained now in demonstrating that two separate governments, in two separate countries, with two separate economies, can effectively partner to put a price on carbon and reduce greenhouse gas emissions is invaluable to accelerating national and international efforts to address climate change.” However, California’s cap and trade program is less than a year old and already several lawsuits have been filed challenging various aspects of the program. So the jury is still out as to whether California’s program will succeed. Moreover, the addition of Quebec will make the cap and trade program more complicated (and mistake prone) without offering a meaningful test run that could be expected of a larger, more complex regional program. Nonetheless, given the problems with the Kyoto Protocol and the ETS, the need for a successful model is certainly there, and California and Quebec may be the start of such a model. In the interim, California and Quebec will undoubtedly have to iron out a number of issues (ranging from the integrity of offsets to the logistics of operating a linked market in two languages). In the event that the California-Quebec market sets the tone for a revamped European system or a new Kyoto, monitoring the developments of the North American effort will be a key task for businesses and governments (not only within California and Quebec, but in other states and provinces as well), as they may be incorporated into the system at some point in the future. Marc Luesebrink is of counsel in the Los Angeles office of Manatt, Phelps & Phillips. He has extensive experience advising both private industry and public sector clients on environmental and land use matters. Earlier in his career, he served as a Senior Attorney at Southern California Edison and Deputy Attorney General in the Office of the California Attorney General. Mr. Luesebrink can be reached at (310) 312-4261 or mluesebrink@manatt.com . This column is part of a series of articles by law firm Manatt, Phelps & Phillips, LLP’s Energy, Environment & Natural Resources practice. The first column in the third edition of this series discussed What the Sequester Means for Environmental Regulation . Continue reading
Diapason To Launch ForestCare Investment Fund
Diapason to launch ForestCare Investment Fund Mon, 20/05/2013 – 12:03 Independent commodity investment firm Diapason Commodities Management is to launch the ForestCare Investment Fund, an institutional product investing in tangible forestry assets. The ForestCare investment universe will cover forest plantations and resulting activities and services such as forest management, wood production and processing, and all investments will be subject to a strict environmental, social and governance (ESG) filter prior to being included in the portfolio. The fund will take a multi-asset class approach, investing in equities, bonds, forest plots, and forest-related derivatives. Forest plots will form up to 20 per cent of the portfolio where revenue will come from both forestry products and capital gains, and will include plots or land leases exclusively in Europe (land partially or totally covered by forest) to take advantage of the comparatively low levels of private forestry investment in this region. As well as the ownership and operation of European forest plots, the fund will also invest in shares and bonds of companies operating responsibly in the forestry industry, as well as bonds of public and private sector debtors issued to finance projects in this sector. Also included will be forest-related derivatives and other investment instruments related to the forestry theme, including biodiversity credits, credits related to mitigating deforestation (REDD credits) and carbon credits. Mark McDonnell, managing director of Diapason Commodities Management, says: “ForestCare is a completely new way of approaching investment in forestry and with our approach to bio-diversity in forests this investment opportunity has forest sustainability at its core. Crucially, the fund is structured to reconcile economic profitability with the need to make intelligent use of natural resources – providing investors with a diversified portfolio which is uncorrelated with other asset classes.” ForestCare is aimed at the pension fund and institutional investor market and will have three monthly liquidity and a minimum investment of EUR125,000 for the A class and EUR1,000,000 for institutional (I) class. Continue reading




