Tag Archives: europe
COLUMN-US Climate Plan May Boost Cap And Trade: Wynn
Source: Reuters – Wed, 26 Jun 2013 05:11 PM Author: Reuters (The author is a Reuters market analyst. The views expressed are his own.) By Gerard Wynn LONDON, June 26 (Reuters) – President Barack Obama’s climate plan, unveiled this week, may boost regional schemes to cut greenhouse gas emissions, known as cap and trade, four years after the United States failed to pass legislation for a nationwide programme. Unlike Europe, the United States has no national cap and trade scheme to combat carbon emissions. The U.S. Congress considered but ultimately failed to bring in a national scheme in a climate bill which stalled in the Senate in 2009. After this failure, there is no hope of a repeated attempt any time soon. But Obama’s new climate plan could enhance the regional cap and trade markets and cement their future. Such schemes allocate a fixed quota of carbon emissions permits to industry and these can be traded between the participants. The present U.S. schemes are the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) of nine northeast states, which caps power sector carbon emissions, and California’s economy-wide programme. Obama, facing Republican opposition, is by-passing Congress and turning instead to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to bring in carbon curbs on existing power plants. He has directed the agency to finalise such emissions standards by June 2015 under the existing Clean Air Act (CAA). If the agency can fend off litigation, a new EPA proposal could link and boost existing regional cap and trade schemes and possibly even expand these to neighbouring states. But such a by-passing of Congress will face legal challenges, on the basis that the Clean Air Act was not originally intended to combat climate change. There is little precedent, for example, to implement emissions trading through the Act. DETAIL It is too early to judge the cost or ambition of Obama’s climate plan, given its low level of detail. “What follows is a blueprint for steady, responsible national and international action to slow the effects of climate change so we leave a cleaner, more stable environment for future generations,” Obama’s “Climate Action Plan” stated. The plan did include goals to cut cumulative carbon emissions from running appliances and government buildings and a target for federal agencies to source their energy from renewable sources. But its most interesting aspect is the plan to curb carbon dioxide emissions from existing power plants, where it is clear that emissions markets will be one model for implementation. Obama entitled the new carbon emissions standards, “Flexible Carbon Pollution Standards for Power Plants”, in a memo directing the EPA administrator. “You shall ensure, to the greatest extent possible, that you develop approaches that allow the use of market-based instruments, performance standards, and other regulatory flexibilities; (and) ensure that the standards enable continued reliance on a range of energy sources and technologies,” he said in the memo. In international climate policy, “flexible” and “market-based” are jargon for emissions trading. NO CONSENSUS The Clean Air Act has few precedents for enacting emissions trading. One is the sulphur dioxide (SO2) allowance trading system, intended to address the threat of acid rain. That market was introduced through amendments to the Act in 1990, which passed both the House of Representatives (401-21) and the Senate (89-11) by wide margins. No such political consensus exists now, ruling out new amendments to accommodate carbon. Instead Obama is using direct action through existing clauses in the Act, in sections 111( and 111(d). These make no direct mention of carbon or emissions trading. Section 111(d) sets guidelines for state regulation of existing sources of pollutants, such as power plants, where in the past EPA has issued model plans for adoption by the states. EPA has made one ill-fated attempt to interpret section 111(d) as allowing an emissions trading program, according to the Washington-based think-tank “Resources for the Future”. (“Greenhouse gas regulation under the Clean Air Act”, April 2010) That unsuccessful regulation in 2005 would have established a trading program for mercury emissions from power plants. “Although the D.C. Circuit rejected EPA’s mercury rule, it did so on other grounds – the court gave no indication that emissions trading under the New Source Performance Standards program was itself problematic (though it is of course possible that the court simply did not reach the issue),” the report said. CAP AND TRADE Despite such legal hurdles, emissions trading and other market approaches may offer the most flexibility for states to interpret an emissions standard, and so minimise costs. The U.S. environmental group the Natural Resources Defense Council gave an example of how it could work at the end of last year. (“Closing the Power Plant Carbon Pollution Loophole”, December 2012) EPA would set state-specific performance standards for power plants, based on the energy mix in each state. “NRDC’s proposal is designed to give power plant owners freedom to choose how they would achieve the required emission reductions, giving credit for increases in energy efficiency and electricity generation using renewable sources and allowing emission-rate averaging among fossil fuelfired power plants,” it said. The plan sounds much like Obama’s memo to the EPA. States could meet the emissions standards either through their own crediting schemes, which give utilities flexibility in how they reached a target across a number of power plants, or they could tap into existing cap and trade schemes. If EPA introduced an average limit on carbon emissions in the power sector, utilities already operating within a regional cap and trade scheme could meet such limits by buying carbon allowances. The effect would be to push up carbon prices and probably trading volumes and liquidity in such regional cap and trade schemes by increasing demand. (Reporting by Gerard Wynn. Editing by Jane Merriman) Continue reading
Carbon Permit “Backloading” Fight Continues in European Parliament
A European Commission plan to delay the auctioning of millions of carbon permits received a new boost last week, after a European Parliament committee signed off on the proposal. The legislation must still be approved by the full Parliament later this summer, which had rejected an earlier version. The move to delay permit auctions – a practice known as backloading – is aimed at boosting the prices of such permits, which underpin the EU’s Emissions Trading System (ETS). An oversupply of permits, combined with the bloc’s broader economic struggles, has led permit prices to hover at dangerously low levels, reaching less than €3 per tonne in April and generally about €5 per tonne. The plan approved by the Parliament’s environment committee last week includes various changes from the original proposal, which EU parliamentarians had rejected in April. (See Bridges Weekly, 18 April 2013 ) One of the most notable modifications involves language assuring that backloading will only be a one-off event, if done at all. The European Commission would also need to conduct an impact assessment showing there to be no “significant risk” of companies in the sectors concerned relocating outside the EU. In addition, carbon credits would need to be returned to the market “in a predictable and linear manner,” beginning from the year after the last permit has been withheld. The original legislation had called for reintroducing these permits in 2019-20. As in the original plan, only 900 million carbon permits would be withheld – out of 1.7 billion currently in the market. Six hundred million of these would need to be made available for funding the development of low-carbon technologies. “We now have broader support for a solution that will allow the ETS to fulfil its purpose and support innovation to tackle climate change,” said Matthias Groote, a German member of the S&D group who serves as the legislation’s rapporteur in Parliament. Plenary vote in July The proposal will next face a vote by the full Parliament during its 3 July plenary session in Strasbourg. However, even if EU lawmakers sign off on the revised measure, it will still need the approval of individual EU governments, under the bloc’s co-decision rules. The proposal has been controversial in the EU, over concerns that delaying permit auctions could increase energy costs and lower confidence in the overall ETS. Others have also argued that the EU emissions scheme has broader structural problems that backloading alone cannot solve. “As I have always said, backloading is a quick, temporary fix,” Groote said last week. “Structural reform of our Emissions Trading System will follow to ensure it remains the cornerstone of EU’s climate policy and an inspiration to others around the world.” Opposition to the plan is largely expected to come from Poland, a country heavily reliant on coal, and Germany, which has spoken out about the potential for rising energy costs. The United Kingdom, meanwhile, has been a strong backer of the plan, calling also for deeper reform of climate change policy. Compromises render the proposal “toothless,” critics say Observers say that the upcoming plenary vote is likely to have important ramifications for the credibility of Europe’s carbon market and the bloc’s overall efforts to meet its climate change goals. The EU has said that it aims to have almost carbon-free electricity by 2050, and has pledged to reduce emissions by 20 percent from 1990 levels by 2020. However, the “watered down” nature of the new backloading proposal has drawn criticism from some environmentalists, who say that the compromises made in order to win over previous opponents have rendered the plan “toothless.” The new version “is now only a shadow of what it should have been,” said Greenpeace EU climate policy director Joris den Blanken. Though some environmentalists find that the proposal does not go far enough to address the ETS’ problems, private sector critics have argued that the proposed backloading could drive up the cost of doing business in the EU and push economic opportunities elsewhere. BusinessEurope, a lobby group of industrial and employers’ federations, has opposed the initiative, calling it an “unnecessary political intervention into the ETS market.” The group added that European industry is on track for meeting its 2020 carbon reduction target. ICTSD reporting; “EU politicians to try again to rescue carbon market,” REUTERS, 19 June 2013; “EU Parliament Committee Approves Proposal to Fix Carbon Market,” WALL STREET JOURNAL, 19 June 2013. Continue reading
IEA: Renewable Power To Exceed Gas By 2016 And Double Nuclear
Silvio Marcacci CleanTechnica Natural gas is widely considered the bridge to take us from fossil fuel dependence to a clean energy future – but that bridge may be a lot shorter than anyone could have predicted. Global renewable electricity production by region image via IEA The International Energy Agency predicts power generation from renewable sources will exceed natural gas and be twice the contribution from nuclear energy globally by 2016 – just three short years from now. IEA’s second-annual Medium-Term Renewable Energy Market Report (MTRMR) forecasts renewable generation will grow 40 per cent in the next five years despite difficult economic conditions. Wind and solar lead renewables charge Renewable energy is now the fastest-growing sector of the global power market, and will represent 25 per cent of all energy generation worldwide by 2018, up from 20 per cent in 2011. In addition, renewable electricity generation is expected to reach 6,850 terawatt-hours (TWh) and total installed renewable capacity should hit 2,350 gigawatts (GW), both by 2018. Wind and solar photovoltaic generation is powering this jump, and non-hydro renewable power will double from 4 per cent of gross generation in 2011 to 8 per cent in 2018. IEA cites two main drivers for their incredible outlook: accelerating investment and deployment, and growing cost competitiveness versus fossil fuels. Strongest growth in developing countries Even though government funding has been inconsistent, private investment has remained strong, especially in developing economies. Rural electrification, energy poverty, and rising demand have been major challenges for policymakers in these countries, and renewables have become an increasingly attractive option for diverse and non-polluting power. Countries with non-hydro renewable capacity above 100MW image via IEA Non-developed countries, led by China , are expected to contribute two-thirds of all renewable market growth between now and 2018, compensating for slower growth and market volatility acorss Europe and the US. Indeed, non-hydro renewable power will make up 11 per cent of gross generation in these countries by 2018, up from 7 per cent in 2012. By itself, China will account for 310GW, or 40 per cent of all global renewable power capacity increases over this time period. Falling costs, rising capacity Solving energy poverty issues without harmful emissions is key to renewables growth , but the larger reason for IEA’s outlook is more likely falling costs. The report finds renewables now cost-competitive with fossil fuels across many countries and a wide set of circumstances. Solar PV annual capacity additions by region image via IEA IEA notes wind is competitive with new fossil fuel in multiple markets, including Brazil, South Africa, Mexico, and New Zealand, and solar is competitive both in markets with high peak prices and decentralized power needs. “As their costs continue to fall, renewable power sources are increasingly standing on their own merits versus new fossil-fuel generation,” said Maria van der Hoeven of IEA. IEA – policy uncertainty is public enemy #1 However, the IEA warns renewables still face a challenging future. Global investment fell in 2012, and policy uncertainties loom over clean energy technology in several important markets. In addition, grid integration challenges have materialized in some regions as renewables penetration has hit new levels. “Policy uncertainty is public enemy number one,” said Van der Hoeven . “Many renewables no longer require high economic incentives, but they do still need long-term policies that provide a predictable and reliable market and regulatory framework.” Read more: http://www.businesss…r#ixzz2XPwhHSpo Continue reading




