News
CML warns Scottish Govt that rent controls could have adverse effects
Proposals by the Scottish Government to introduce new rules for the private rented sector could have a negative impact on buy to let lending, according to the Council of Mortgage Lenders. It has sent a detailed response to a consultation document issued by the Scottish Government, and while it recognises that some of the proposals will benefit the sector, others are likely to have a detrimental effect. In particular the CML is concerned about rent controls. In its reply it says that rent levels in Scotland are complex picture and while some areas such as Aberdeen and Edinburgh may have seen above average increases in rent levels these are very much as a result of demand exceeding supply. It points out that these areas are also seeing above average house price increases for the same reason and the long term solution has to be to increase the supply of housing in areas where this is an under supply. ‘We believe that the introduction of rent control is likely to dampen appetite amongst institutional investors to invest in the sector, will impact adversely on the availability of buy to let mortgages, will result in higher rents being set at the outset to compensate for lower rent increases during the rental term and could impact on quality if a rental yield cannot be achieved to allow continued investment in the property,’ the CML says. ‘Overall we believe the introduction of any form of rent control is likely to reduce investment in the sector thus reducing the supply which is badly needed to meet housing need. Currently we do not believe there is any need for the Scottish Government to take any action as there is no evidence base which would justify it doing so,’ it adds. The CML explains that while there are a number of models which could be selected in terms of rent controls, any such model would have to be an effective, transparent and a fair way of increasing rents so that it was attractive to both landlords and tenants. ‘A careful balance would need to be struck between landlords’ expectations over future rental yields and the expectation of tenants,’ it adds. The CML document welcomes the development of a model tenancy agreement and modernised grounds for possession. ‘However we believe that a number of the proposals contained in the paper are likely to have the unintended consequences of both reducing investment in the sector and the supply of private rented sector housing,’ it points out. These include the removal of the no-fault ground for re-gaining possession, the removal of the ability to continue tenancies on a month to month basis at the end of their term and potential controls over rents. ‘We believe that landlords need to have confidence in their ability to end a tenancy when they need to do so otherwise this may discourage future investment in the sector. Existing arrangements provide flexibility for both landlords and tenants…. Continue reading
Warning over use of photos in tenancy disputes
The use of technology in inventories appears to save time and money, but UK lettings agents and landlords are being warned that in reality it is not full proof. Often technology does not allow for the inclusion of sufficient detail to provide indisputable evidence of the original condition at the start of a tenancy, according to research by My Property Inventories. The perception of inventories by some lettings agents is that inventories can be very long, time consuming and somewhat of a laborious process. As a result, several landlords and management companies opt for the use of technology in inventories believing it will save them time and money. The use of technology in inventories claims to help landlords and management companies to complete inventories in a matter of minutes, with the ability to add large quantities of photographs, which can provide evidence in tenancy, dispute claims. But according to Danny Zane, director of My Property Inventories, in many tenancy dispute cases, the adjudicators are likely to reject some technology based inventories, as they cannot deliver the level of detail required which means that the landlord can lose hundreds of pounds in lost cases. ‘Many landlords and agents are using digital evidence to replace essential written descriptions in inventories, at check-in and check-out, leaving landlords exposed to potentially costly disputes over damage and other issues. The law clearly states that the deposit remains the tenant’s money and that they are entitled to get it back at the end of their stay, provided they have met the terms of the tenancy agreement, so the onus lies with the agent or landlord to provide proof of any proposed deductions,’ he said. ‘Without an accurate and properly detailed inventory, a landlord has no evidence to prove that the property has been damaged in any way during the tenancy and therefore will find it almost impossible to withhold any deposit money from the tenants. A glossy inventory that relies heavily on photographs will be of little use in a dispute. In fact, there is no point in producing a picture book for an inventory, with very little proper description and hundreds of photographs. Inventories like these just do not provide enough detail,’ he explained. ‘Photography and video are great for large areas of damage such as carpet burns, serious damage to worktops and interior décor etc. However, they are not so good for showing really fine detail of the sort of problems that occur most frequently on a check-out, such as small chips and scratches in sinks and baths, knife marks on worktops, scratches to halogen hobs. All of which will cause financial loss to the landlord if negligence can’t be proved,’ he added. The firm points out that inventory reports should contain a full description of a property and its contents, with detail on… Continue reading
US housing market set to see strong demand from first time buyers in 2015
The growing gap between housing's low and top tiers in the United States is expected to restore healthy demand for first time buyers and those moving up the housing ladder. 2015 has the promise of a transitional year where full buyer momentum in the low and mid tiers reinforce a strong housing recovery, according to the latest analysis report from Clear Capital. It says that sustained national price growth in the low tier segment, once driven by investor activity, is good news for first time buyers and also encouraging is the number of potential buyers locked into underwater mortgages has been steadily decreasing. The recent rise in home prices continue to bring more home owners out of negative equity and with more equity to play with, mid-tier home owners could move up, creating more opportunity and driving healthy demand in the low and mid tiers of the market. ‘While we are expecting price growth to moderate across all tiers in 2015, the top tier’s quarterly growth rate fell to 0.3% in the fourth quarter, where it had been holding steady at around 1% through the first three quarters of 2014,’ said Alex Villacorta, vice president of research and analytics at Clear Capital.. The report shows that year on year this tier experienced the lowest price growth rate of 3.6% among the three national tiers. At its current pace, continued moderation in the top tier could push quarterly price growth into negative territory in 2015. January data also reveals the low tier holding on to double digit gains year on year at 10.2% and healthy quarter on quarter gains of 1.5%. The firm believes that this divide between a healthy low tier and stalling top tier could kick off a domino effect. Stalling prices in the top tier of the market could create the perception of a good deal. This instils confidence in mid-tier home owners, motivating them to move up to the top tier. In turn, this opens up more opportunity for low tier home owners to move up to the mid-tier. Creating new opportunity in the low tier could entice potential first time buyers to enter the market. This domino effect could be the catalyst for balanced demand across all sectors of the market. Regionally, the Midwest continues to lead the growth and year on year held on to double digit gains in the low tier segment at 13.6%, while the top tier fell to 3.3%. This gap between growth in the low and top tiers was also recorded on a quarterly basis, with the low tier growing at 1.7% and relatively flat growth in the top tier at 0.5%. The Midwest led the nation in the all tier segment, with quarter on quarter growth at 0.9%, narrowly edging the West at 0.7%. The Midwest is the only region currently seeing price appreciation in the low and mid tiers, growing concurrently above 1%. The firm explained that a moderating top tier could incentivize… Continue reading




